About Upstart Loans
Modern science hasn’t brought us true artificial intelligence—yet, but it has brought us computer algorithms that can underwrite loans with a great deal of accuracy, faster and for less money than traditional methods. Because of this, a flood of software-based lenders have recently entered the market, promising to help with everything from home loans to student loan refinancing.
One of these is Upstart Loans, a marketplace lender who claims to specialize in providing unsecured personal loans to those who are just starting their careers, and who might be short on work and credit history. But, by also looking at an applicant’s education and area of study (more about this soon), Upstart promises to deliver “fair and fast” loans at lower rates.
In fact, we’re told that the average Upstart borrower saves 27% compared to their credit card rates! To accomplish this, the process works over 3 steps:
- Check your rate in 2 minutes (without affecting your credit score) by answering a few questions about your education and employment.
- Upon approval and acceptance of your loan, you’ll be able to get your money as soon as the next day.
- Set up automated payments until your loan is repaid in full.
Together, this is why Upstart claims they’ve originated more than 32,000 loans to date.
These seem like some impressive numbers, especially if you’re looking to make smart financial decisions, but don’t have the work history and credit score required for a traditional loan. Does this necessarily mean that Upstart Loans is right for you? Do you have other options?
To gain a better understanding of what you’ll get with Upstart Loans, let’s take a look at how the company works.
How Does Upstart Loans Work?
For decades, most lenders have based an applicant’s creditworthiness on their FICO score and employment history. However, according to Upstart Loans’ co-founder Dave Girouard, the reality is that young people are less likely default on loans than some people twice their age.
To access this huge, untapped market of “future prime” borrowers, Upstart Loans utilizes much broader underwriting criteria than most other lenders, which is handled via a proprietary algorithm. This algorithm looks a standard things like FICO score and employment history, but also “other signals of their potential, including schools attended, area of study, academic performance/GPA, standardized test scores, and work history.”
From there, Upstart’s algorithm develops a statistical model of the applicant’s financial capacity and personal propensity to repay. Then, it models 50,000+ scenarios in a few seconds, including “repayments, delinquencies and prepayments of every loan, month by month,” to determine the applicant’s likelihood of default and loan APR.
According to Upstart, their model is continuously refined by comparing it to real-world results. To date, however, roughly 98% of all the company’s loans are current or paid in full.
Investing In Upstart’s Peer-to-Peer Lending Network
If you’re an investor (versus a borrower) Upstart also allows individuals to invest in the company’s loans, even through their IRAs.
Upstart also claims P2P investors can assemble a portfolio of loans based on an applicant’s modeled likelihood of default,” depending on your risk and return criteria.
Before moving on, let’s talk about some of the terms we’ve been using frequently.
What’s the Difference Between Marketplace & Peer-to-Peer Lending?
In practice, marketplace lending and peer-to-peer lending both reference the same thing; a company finds a qualified loan applicant, brings the applicant’s information to a peer (which could be an individual, a group of individuals, or other companies), who then provides the funds for these loans. Since these individuals or companies generally aren’t banks, they might not be subject to the same regulations and/or bureaucratic slowdowns.
Although the concept of marketplace lending isn’t new, many recent P2P lenders have added proprietary algorithms to their arsenal that can underwrite a pre-approval in seconds. Taken together, this means that modern marketplace lenders can generally deliver faster approval times, broader underwriting criteria, and lower interest rates than traditional institutions.
This is part of the reason why we’re seen a huge explosion in the number of marketplace lenders entering every aspect of the market recently, including CommonBond, LendingHome, SoFi, RapidLoansDirect, Headway Capital, and many others.
Pro tip: As you can see, the marketplace lending industry covers a vast amount of territory; everything from personal lenders like Upstart to payday lenders. While personal loans can be a smart financial decision, most professionals recommend avoiding payday loans unless you have no other option.
With this in mind, how much will you pay for an Upstart loan?
How Much Does an Upstart Loan Cost?
Upstart offers fixed loans from $1K to $50K, with 3 and 5-year repayment terms. APRs range between 4.66% and 29.99% APRs, depending on what you’ll be using your loan for (e.g. to pay off credit cards, consolidate debt, refinance student loans, etc.) as well as your underwriting criteria.
Note: Upstart claims their average APR is 16% and average repayment term is 36 months.
The only fees listed are a 1%-6% origination fee. For example: If you take out a $30K loan and have a 3% origination fee, you’ll be charged an extra $900. However, there are no prepayment penalties.
As soon as you’re approved, Upstart might be able to transfer your money to your account as soon as the next day, although “loans used to fund education related expenses are subject to a 3 business day wait period between loan acceptance and funding in accordance with federal law.”
Have questions? Upstart’s customer service department can be reached at 855-438-8778, via email at email@example.com, or through online chat.
Will You Be Approved for an Upstart Loan?
Since marketplace lending of this scale is a relatively recent phenomenon, there have been a few growing pains over the years. For example, the industry isn’t as tightly regulated as more traditional lenders, and these companies are still trying to find their comfortable niche.
What we mean is that many of these companies (similar to Upstart) like to talk about helping younger clients, who perhaps don’t have the credit and/or employment history to obtain loans through banks. However, what they might gloss over is that you’ll still probably need a solid credit score and income level in order to qualify at a competitive APR.
For example, according to Upstart’s own numbers, their clients have an average FICO score of 692 and an annual income of $99,720. On top of this, 90.9% are college graduates, and 78.4% use the funds to refinance credit cards.
So, if you don’t have the employment and credit history necessary for traditional bank loans, but also lack a fairly high income and/or credit score, Upstart Loans might not be able to help out, either.
What about Upstart’s real-world applicants? Have they been able to qualify? If so, did they find the process enjoyable?
Are There Any Online Reviews for Upstart Loans?
Pretty much wherever you look, Upstart Loans seems to come with positive feedback.
For example, nearly 1,700 customers gave the company an average 4.7-star rating on CreditKarma, while 300+ gave Upstart an average rating of 9.2 on BestCompany. Common compliments seemed to reference a simple online application process, competitive rates, and responsive customer service.
On the other hand, the most common complaints appeared to revolved around high origination fees (one claimed their origination fee increased their working APR by 4%), and high credit score and income requirements.
In addition to what we talked about in the previous section, BestCompany notes that the average Upstart client also has a debt-to-income ratio under 20%. They go on to support our findings by writing:
“Since most borrowers are looking to consolidate debt, the above credentials can be difficult to meet. This is a common complaint found in our User Reviews.”
Who Founded Upstart Loans?
Co-founded by ex-Googler Dave Girouard in 2014, Upstart Network, Inc. originally offered peer-to-peer loans that “enabled individuals to raise money by agreeing to share a percent of their future income” for a period of 5 or 10 years. Soon after in May 2014, this funding option was stopped.
Today, along with co-founders Paul Gu and Anna M. Counselman, Upstart’s income prediction model has originated more than $420 million in loans across 33,000+ borrowers.
All of Upstart’s loans are made by Cross River Bank, an FDIC insured New Jersey state chartered commercial bank. The company is backed by Google Ventures, Khosla Ventures, and many others, including Dallas Mavericks owner and Shark Tank star Mark Cuban.
Is Upstart Loans the Right Marketplace Lender for You?
Whether it’s individuals with lower credit scores or those with student loan debt, most P2P lenders have their own niche, as well as their own marketing angle. From Upstart’s perspective, it seems to be their fast approval and funding process, along with their focus on individuals with short income and credit histories.
However, even after just a little bit of research, you’ll quickly find that Upstart isn’t necessarily unique in this aspect, and it all comes down to APR. And to find out the best one based on your specific criteria, you’ll need to pre-apply for rates. The good news is that, for the most part, this won’t affect your credit.
Did you apply for an Upstart loan? Were you approved? What did you experience during the process? Tell the world about it in your very own review below!
More on the Topic:
- “It’s Not My Fault!” & Four Other Reasons You Don’t Have Financial Freedom
- Financing Your Car: 6 Expert Tips on Landing a Great Auto Loan
- How Robo-Advisors Make Investing Easier Than Ever: Beginner’s Guide
I applied for a $9,600 loan that was rejected, however, I received an email stating I was not qualified for the initial amount but was approved for a smaller loan amount.
I sent in all the documents required, WHICH by the way seemed extreme and included some scary required documents. BUT I assumed I had already been approved (things like bank routing numbers were asked, voided checks, payroll to match bank statements). All were sent. The phone conversations had very strange questions.
So after fulfilling all these requests, I sent an email stating I am done jumping through hoops, you have everything requested. Withing 5 minutes, they sent me a decline notice and the reason was too many inquiries on my credit. BULL CRAP reason. I then simply requested a credit increase from my bank and was approved in 20 minutes.
I believe that Upstart isn't what they say and something very strange is going on there.
Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend
1 out 2 people found this review helpful
If I could, I would rate zero stars. Bait and switch tactics, employees clearly don't know how to process loans or much less read a W2. I was offered a loan at almost 29%, then went to my local credit union and got one at 6%.
Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend