About Amica Auto Insurance

Named as the oldest mutual insurer in the country, Amica Auto Insurance claims to provide an affordable auto (or motorcycle) policy that’s customized to fit your needs.

Amica’s auto insurance policies feature a variety of coverages, including a range of deductibles, coverage for you and your passengers, liability insurance for others, roadside assistance, glass coverage, and more.

Compared to other companies, Amica’s Platinum Choice Auto program features the ability to earn Advantage points by referring others to the company, completing a year of good driving, taking out additional policies, and so forth. Then, the points can be applied toward accident forgiveness and reduced deductibles.

With Amica Auto Coverage, you’ll also find ID fraud monitoring, rental coverage, and full glass coverage.

Sound like we’re speaking a different language? Don’t worry, we’ll explain more about these coverages next.

Amica Auto Insurance Coverage

This can vary by state, but most auto insurance policies are divided into 4 sections, designated by letter:

  • Part A – Liability Coverage: Liability is what covers someone else if you cause an accident that leads to injury or property damage. Liability coverage can be in split limits (e.g. 250500/100) or combined single limits (CSL) (e.g. 300,000).
  • Part B – Medical Expenses: If someone in your vehicle is injured, medical expenses coverage provides money for immediate needs, such as ambulance rides, ER visits, etc. This will be a single limit, and usually for a lower amount (e.g. $5K, $10K, etc.).
  • Part C – Uninsured Motorist (UM) Coverage – Covers you in the event you’re involved in an accident with someone who doesn’t have insurance, or in a hit and run accident.
  • Part D – Comprehensive & Collision Coverage – Like the name implies, collision coverage takes effective whenever your vehicle has collided with a fixed object, such as another car or a building. Collision is typically the most expensive single section of an auto policy. On the other hand, comprehensive is “other than collision,” and would cover specific instances such as striking an animal, falling objects (such as hail), and more. There are usually deductibles in $100, $250, $500, and $1000 increments.

These 4 sections, or coverages, make up the core of any auto policy, and will be offered regardless of the insurance company you choose. Most auto insurance companies also offer some form of rental car coverage, roadside assistance, glass coverage, etc, so there’s nothing necessarily unique about Amica there.

What’s going to differ between these companies, however, is how much money you’ll pay for these coverages.

How Much Do Amica Auto Insurance Policies Cost?

Like Learning? Here’s the detailed answer: Decades ago, auto insurance policies were simple to rate. So simple, that you could actually calculate them by hand.

Today, it’s a completely different story. Nowadays, most insurance carriers have begun using something called multivariate rating. Before your eyes glaze over, this just means that anything that can be changed on your auto policy has the ability to affect its price; things that in the past had no bearing on premium.

A couple examples:

  1. You obtain a new auto quote on 12/1, effective 12/31. However, you wait until 12/30 to contact your agent and start your policy, so your premium goes up as a result.
  2. You obtain an auto quote on 6/15, but don’t start the policy until 8/1. In that month and a half, your credit rating (a big component of your overall insurance score) increases, so your policy premium decreases.
  3. You original auto premium is $750. However, you failed to tell your agent that you had a lapse in insurance 3 years ago. Your premium skyrockets to $1,500.

Of course, this is in addition to the usual rating factors like driving records (accidents and tickets), prior losses, age, type of vehicle you drive (and how you drive it; e.g. work, pleasure, annual miles, etc.), and more.

Although most insurance companies use multivariate rating systems, how each of these variables interacts with one another differs from company to company. This is based on their proprietary actuarial tables (the math behind their rates).

Too busy? Here’s the quick answer: Even if you and your neighbor had the exact same vehicle, the same driving record, and you both obtained a quote through Amica, it’s likely that you’d have very different premiums. Why? There are dozens of different factors (and hundreds of thousands of combinations for these factors) that alter what you pay.

As you can see, while most of the top insurance companies offer relatively similar coverages, how they calculate their premiums couldn’t be more different.

Pricing aside, is Amica a Good Company?

The 411 On Amica Auto Coverage

Amica Mutual Company is based out of Lincoln, RI, and is somewhat different than many other direct writer insurance carriers in that they’re also a mutual insurance company. This means they’re owned by all of the policyholders, who receive a cut of the overall profits (known as a dividend) once per year.

Amica had an A+ BBB rating at the time of our research. There were 72 total complaints, which most commonly referenced price increases and poor claims experiences.

Amica also had an A++ (superior) financial strength rating with AM Best, which is good, since you always want to make sure your insurance carrier has enough money to pay for claims!

From a customer perspective, Amica Auto Insurance reviews seem to be mixed.

For example, on ConsumerAffairs.com, some former policyholders claim to have had good experiences with Amica, although many more claimed to have experienced poor customer service, difficulty/confusion with claims, and high premiums. Average rating of one star.

Based on 19 CreditKarma reviews, Amica Auto Insurance had an average rating of 3 stars. Again, some customers were pleased, although just as many seemed miffed about rate increases, poor customer service, and poor claims handling.

On Credio.com, Amica scored a 4.1 average rating. There, complaints also referenced poor customer service, claims problems, and insufficient cancellation notices.

Will you experience the same with Amica? There’s no way to know, although it’s certainly worth keeping in mind.

But enough about other people. Where does this leave you?

Should You Get Behind the Wheel of Amica Auto Coverage?

Most insurance professionals recommend never choosing coverage based on price alone. Just because an insurance company has low rates, this doesn’t mean they’ll provide solid customer support, an easy claims process, or even the money to help you in your time of need.

If you’re new to shopping for insurance, this is where an independent agent can come in handy. They’ll be able to shop all the companies they represent, not just for the cheapest rate, but also for a reputable company you’ll be pleased with.

Because Amica doesn’t work with agents (remember, they’re a direct writer), you won’t have this option. The good news is that most of the company’s customers appear pleased (especially considering their overall volume)—not to mention their high BBB and AM Best ratings—so you probably will too.

Sign Up for HighYa Newsletter

Sign up for HighYa newsletter and get our best content delivered in your inbox as well as 3 free eBooks to help you save money and shop smarter. Enter your email below to get started!

1 Consumer Review for Amica Auto Insurance

Average Consumer Rating: 1.0
Rating Snapshot:
5 star: 0 4 star: 0 3 star: 0 2 star: 0 1 star:  1
Bottom Line: 0% would recommend it to a friend
  • 20 out 29 people found this review helpful


    • Savannah, GA,
    • Oct 13, 2017
    • Verified Reviewer

    Amica is a disgrace to insurance companies. A person who has their insurance plan hit me back in December and was given a citation by the police for being at fault. The police report clearly states that the driver was rude and reckless, and should be held responsible. To get out of not paying my medical bills and other expenses, this company claimed their driver was not at fault. How disgusting and low can a company be by trying not to do handle its responsibility? Take hold of your responsibility and pay my bills! I still have the police report!

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

    Help others find the most helpful reviews

    Was this review helpful?

    yes no
    Comments (1)
    View all 1 commentsHide comments
    • Feb 18, 2018

      Fred Johnson


      You should file a complaint with the Georgia Department of Insurance. They'll investigate your claim thoroughly, and if you have enough evidence to support your version of events, they'll force Amica to pay your claim. You have a limited amount of time to file a formal complaint, however (two years in most states), so you should act quickly. Good luck!

    Do you have an account? Log In before commenting.

    (If you don’t have an account – don’t worry, you can create it after)

Showing 1-1 of 1

Write a Review for Amica Auto Insurance!

Share your experience to help others shop smarter & discover great products.

Write a Review