5 Best Websites for Thoughtful Christmas Gifts

Finding just the right Christmas gift for someone takes a lot of thought and planning.

Most of the big-box stores don’t offer the level of unique presents you’re looking for, so you’re left to browse endless “Best Of” articles about unique or random websites for thoughtful gifts.

We did our research this holiday season and came up with five of the best websites for finding unique and thoughtful gifts for friends, family, and co-workers.

Some of these websites are relatively new and some are old favorites, but each of them gives you the chance to find unique – and in some cases, handmade – gifts your recipients are sure to love.

1. eBay: Home to Unique New and Used Gifts

Remember back in the 1990’s when eBay was like the second coming of the retail messiah? Well, it’s still around and as popular as ever. In fact, eBay makes efforts to remind shoppers that their large retail auction site is a desirable holiday shopping hub.

eBay

Suzy Deering, eBay North America’s chief marketing officer, told Business Wire the site’s strength is that you have thousands of options for new or used gifts..

“As a global marketplace, eBay is the only place to find this year’s most in-demand items, from small and mid-size sellers to top brands, to one-of-a-kind personal or bespoke items,” Deering said. “We empower shoppers to be the ultimate gift-givers with our unparalleled selection.”

One of the big reasons why eBay is still a shopping destination, Deering said, is because 74% of consumers say they have a hard time finding the perfect gift at the perfect price.

How you go about finding that perfect Christmas gift at the perfect price takes a little finesse. There are three ways you can buy things on eBay:

  • Auction: You and other people bid for an item. Once the clock on the item hits zero, the highest bid wins.

  • Buy It Now: You buy an item just like you would on Amazon or Target. Click on the “Buy It Now” button, pay for the item, and you’re done.

  • Best Offer: You have three chances to offer a lower price on a Buy It Now item. If your price is accepted, you win the item.

Using Best Offer to Get the Best Deals

While auctions are fun and Buy It Now is simple; we want to focus on Best Offer items. In my experience, Best Offer items are usually things that the seller wants to get rid of but isn't ready to post at a lower price.

All Best Offer items also have a Buy It Now price, but, in my experience, the seller isn’t looking to get the BIN price. They want to sell their item for between 80% and 90% off that price. Formulate your three bids around this strategy.

So, let’s say you find a used iPhone 7 for $500 that you want to give to your spouse for Christmas. You want your first bid to be 20% of that, or $400. You’ll get a notification as to whether or not the bid was accepted or rejected.

The seller will do one of two things if your price is rejected: a “no” without a counter offer and a “no” with a counter offer.

If they counter offer, you’ll get a better read on what the seller wants to get for the item. Don’t accept this offer, though. My suggestion is to split the difference between 80% and 90% and offer $425 for your second bid.

If that offer is rejected, then you’ve got one last bid – offer 90% of the item and leave it at that. If your offer is accepted, awesome; if it’s rejected, you’re left with the Buy It Now price, which is probably going to be cheaper than what you’ll find on Amazon.

Pros to Using eBay for Christmas Gifts

  • eBay sellers value their reputation, so if your purchase doesn’t meet your expectations, they’ll usually do everything they can to satisfy you, whether it’s a partial refund or return. Remember, though, to make sure returns are accepted by the seller.

  • The Best Offer buying tactic is simple and budget friendly. Since you’re using an 80-85-90% bidding technique, you won’t waste much time. Wait for the response, then bid on that Christmas present again. 

  • You’ve got a huge variety of items from which to choose, as well as plenty of reliable sellers with good reputations.

Cons to Using eBay for Christmas Gifts

  • eBay sellers don’t always ship the item out the day of or day after your purchase, so allow yourself a few weeks for shipping, just in case.

  • Some sellers don’t allow returns, and those who do will require you to pay return shipping.

  • If you’re buying a gift for someone who is out of state, you’ll have to pay twice for shipping – once to get the item, then once to send it to the recipient. You could send the item directly to the recipient, but the packaging for eBay items tends not to have the polished looked of big-box stores.

Related: Amazon Seller Scams: How Scammers Use Amazon Marketplace to Rob Shoppers

2. Bespoke Post: The Perfect Gift for the Guy Who Has Everything

Subscription websites have surged in popularity over the past five years, with companies offering everything from snacks and whiskey to makeup and wine. In fact, CBS News pointed out that subscription-box review website My Subscription Addiction has more than 1,500 different subscriptions listed on its site.

Bespoke Post

“Why have these boxes become so popular,” reporter Aimie Pichhi asked. “It's partly the ‘treat yourself’ mentality of wanting to provide a bit of luxury or pampering for yourself or a friend.”

Bespoke Post is one of the leading subscription boxes for men and a great option for thoughtful Christmas gifts. They offer unique, decidedly manly products that span personal care, style, drinking and more. Here’s how it works:

  • Boxes are $45 per month for subscribers and $55 for a one-time gift purchase.

  • You can pick from a variety of boxes on their website, with each product page describing what’s in the box. Each box has a name indicative of its contents.

  • The box is shipped to the address of your choice, for free.

In our experience, Bespoke boxes have been packaged handsomely, the items in the boxes were quality and the informational card included in each box is a great introduction to where each item was made and why they were chosen for the box. All of this makes for a memorable experience when it comes time to give gifts at Christmas.

The overall experience led Investopedia’s Richard Best to say Bespoke Post is among the best of male-focused subscription boxes.

“Most men don't like to shop, in stores or online, but some like the idea of a shopper picking things out for them that they would not ordinarily try on their own,” Best wrote. “That is the special brand identity Bespoke Post has created with its subscribers.”

To judge the value of a Bespoke package, we shopped prices on items in the Mangia box, which includes a pasta machine, cookbook, wooden spoon and bag of semolina flour:

  • Weston pasta machine – $43 ($28.62 + $14.48 shipping from Walmart)
  • The Frankies cookbook – $20.70 (free shipping from Barnes & Noble)
  • Olive-wood spoon – $9.68 (free shipping on Amazon w/$49 min. purchase)
  • Organic semolina flour – $9.99 (free shipping on Amazon w/$49 min. purchase)

The grand total with shipping included is almost $83, and even without shipping, the price of the items is still around $13 more than what you’d pay for the Bespoke box.

Pros to Using Bespoke Post for Christmas Gifts

  • Makes it easy to buy a gift; there are around 10 choices.
  • Unique – each box has its personality and is more interesting than a gift card or single item.
  • Stylish – the Bespoke brand can appease cool-seekers and average guys.

Cons to Using Bespoke Post for Christmas Gifts

  • Only seven boxes to choose from when we did our research.
  • Most items are limited to food, drink, fashion or personal care.
  • May not be a good fit for someone who doesn’t like to branch out from their traditional gifts.

3. Groupon: Giving a Night Out to Far-Away Friends & Family

The popular coupon site Groupon offers shoppers various discounts on restaurants, activities, travel packages and an interesting mix of products ranging from NFL-themed doormats and Samsung earbuds to luggage tags and dog beds.

Groupon

Their website offers deals in hundreds of cities across the United States and abroad. In fact, I’ve used Groupons in Spain, Florida, and California.

The purchase process on Groupon is easy. You pick the coupon you want; then you pay for it. Easy as that. Each coupon offers a discount on the item, service, event or nosh you buy. Restaurants are a classic example: $10 for $30 worth of food, $5 for $10 and so on.

You can choose to use the Groupon for yourself or send it to someone as a gift. If you choose the gift option, Groupon lets you pick from a variety of e-card styles that add a little flair to the Christmas present.

The coupon is then emailed to the recipient, who clicks on the e-card you sent and downloads your digital present.

Before you buy, though, make sure you read the terms and conditions of the offer you want to buy. Some restaurant coupons, for example, are only good on certain days and for certain meals. Also, all coupons have an expiration date.

See Also: Groupon Getaways: What They Are (and Aren’t) Good For

The ease with which you can buy and use Groupons and the discount concept are what make this one of the best places to get a quick, painless Christmas present.

Pros to Using Groupon for Christmas Gifts

  • You can buy local deals for friends and family who don’t live near you.
  • Using their app can get you additional 20% off on coupons.
  • If a coupon expires, it’s worth whatever dollar amount is listed on the coupon.

Cons to Using Groupon for Christmas Gifts

  • It can be hard to know which restaurants or entertainment venues are good.
  • The recipient may or may not remember the restrictions on the coupon.
  • The coupon may go unused.

4. Etsy: Handmade Gifts With Meaning

If it’s artisanal, rustic Christmas gifts you’re looking for, Etsy, the online marketplace for artists and crafters, is pretty much your retail Disneyland.

Etsy

The website is unique in that all its sellers are offering handmade or vintage goods in the following areas:

  • Clothing & accessories
  • Jewelry
  • Craft supplies & tools
  • Weddings
  • Entertainment
  • Home & living
  • Kids & baby

Each seller has a rating based on what customers have said, and you’ll find that sellers take a lot of pride in their product. All the items I’ve ordered from the site have had unique, detailed packaging that added to the awesomeness of what I bought.

Unlike eBay, Etsy’s products aren’t auctioned off. Think of the site as a big online store. You find something you like for a Christmas present, you buy it and it ships.

We suggest you check out the terms and conditions of each item. Also, contact the seller to find out how long it will take them to create and send you the item you want to buy. Around the holidays, a lot of orders come in and their shipping times may be one or two weeks longer than usual.

Pros to Using Etsy for Christmas Gifts

  • Handmade items you won’t find anywhere else.
  • Large selection of vintage and artisan products.
  • Many sellers put as much effort into packaging as they do into their product.

Cons to Using Etsy for Christmas Gifts

  • Finding truly original pieces is hard. Many jewelry sellers buy bulk supplies, so you’ll see the same charms on necklaces and earrings in many different Etsy stores.
  • Sizing can be tough – clothes and jewelry may not always fit.
  • You get what you pay for. Jewelry under $25 tends to tarnish quickly.

5. Birchbox: A Fun Gift at an Affordable Price

Birchbox is one of the original subscription services out there. Their concept is simple: sell $10 subscription boxes filled with sample-size beauty products.

Birchbox

Birchbox offers beauty boxes for men and women, but since we’ve already covered a man-focused subscription service (Bespoke), we’re going to focus on the female side of Birchbox.

Like Bespoke, Birchbox offers the monthly boxes. Unlike Bespoke, however, you can’t buy their full selection of boxes for gifts. Around the holidays, however, they offer gift cards for 3, 6 and 12 months of boxes .

Beauty products can be tricky, though. There are all kinds of skin types, sensitivities, and preferences, so make sure you take a look at some of the products they sell to get a sense of what your boxes will include.

Here are their categories of women’s boxes:

  • Makeup
  • Hair 
  • Skincare
  • Fragrance
  • Bath & body
  • Lifestyle accessories
  • Tools
  • Nails

There’s no guarantee as to what will show up in your box; you could love it, or you could have it. But, in general, Birchbox is well-loved by its customers.

Pros to Using Birchbox for Christmas Gifts

  • Exciting – products change every month and packaging is great.
  • Sample sizes, so if something doesn’t work for you, you don’t waste tons of money or product.
  • Cheapest of all the major subscription services at $10 per month.

Cons to Using Birchbox for Christmas Gifts

  • For someone with specific makeup needs, Birchbox could be a frustrating experience.
  • No consistency in which products you get.
  • Sample sizes can run out quickly depending on what type of product you get, so you’re always using different products on your skin.

Conclusions About the Best Websites for Thoughtful Holiday Gifts

As consumers, we tend to go with the safe bet that’s or the popular site, which usually means we’re scouring Amazon on Cyber Monday or hitting up Target on Black Friday to snag amazing deals.

Those sites are tried-and-true, and we can’t argue with how great they are, but sometimes it helps to browse sites that offer a wider variety of unique Christmas gifts.

eBay is a great site for variety and, in many cases, bargains can be had by using savvy Best Offer techniques. Bespoke Post is a great place to find a gift for that “man who has everything,” while Groupon allows you to buy coupons you can email to family and friends who live across the country.

Etsy is the kind of online artisan stores; many of their pieces are unique, and you won’t be able to find them anywhere else.

Birchbox is an excellent resource for finding gifts for a female. While they don’t offer a lot of individual boxes for a one-time purchase, you can buy gift cards that can be redeemed for subscriptions of varying length.

If you’re looking for more advice on Christmas shopping, head to our holiday shopping and travel guide section. We’ve got an excellent collection of articles that will help you save money and enjoy your Christmas shopping to the fullest.


J.R. Duren

J.R. Duren is a personal finance reporter who examines credit cards, credit scores and bank products. J.R. is a three-time winner at the Florida Press Club’s Excellence in Journalism contest and his advice has been featured in MSN and Fox’s money sections.


Comments

Want to Learn How to Get and Keep a Good Credit Score?

Our FREE eBook will teach you how to get a good credit score that will help you save thousands by scoring the best deals on loans, insurance, and credit cards. Enter your email below to get a free copy of the eBook and to receive our weekly newsletter!