Cardpool Review: Is It Legit?

By J.R. Duren
HighYa Staff
Updated on: Mar 3, 2020

Cardpool is a gift card exchange marketplace where you can buy and sell gift cards.

The service is a great one around the holidays and birthdays because you might receive a gift card to a store you don’t shop at or to a store that’s not close to where you live.

And, if you’re looking to buy a gift card, you can get discounts on your purchases and, in some cases, get an electronic version of the card in less than a day.

Use our analysis of Cardpool to understand if its buy and sell options are the right solutions for you.

Buying Gift Cards on Cardpool

All gift cards on Cardpool offer discounts ranging from 2% to more than 10%, with some cards discounted as much as 35%. You can search for cards based on the store, or use Cardpool’s Swift Buy tool to find a card based on a dollar value.

Swift Buy is an excellent tool for gifting cards because you can narrow your choices down by how much money you want to spend.

Once you find the card you want, take note of the type of card and where you can use it. The cards you buy will be usable either in-store or in-store or online.

Also, your card will either be an eCard you get within one business day or a paper or plastic card Cardpool sends you via USPS.

Cardpool can be a great option if you are able to locate a gift card that is relevant to your needs and offers 10% or more in discounts.

One big advantage of purchasing gift cards through Cardpool is that they do not charge sales tax, and USPS standard shipping (3-7 business days) is free.

Selling Your Gift Cards on Cardpool

If you received gift cards for your birthday or during the holidays, and you don’t think you’ll use them, Cardpool can be a good place to turn them into cash.

To begin selling, all you need to do is click on the “Sell Gift Card” link on the company’s site, select the card’s vendor from a list (e.g. AMC, Home Depot, etc.), enter the card’s value, and then press the “Get Offer” button.

Cardpool will then immediately provide you with a dollar amount they’re willing to pay for your card.

The higher the demand that exists for a card (e.g. Apple, or Best Buy), the higher the price Cardpool will offer you. This price typically ranges between 80 to 91% of their face value.

On the other hand, the less demand there is for a merchant, the lower the percentage Cardpool will offer you.

If you accept their offer, you have two options for payment: an Amazon gift card or a check in the mail. If you choose the Amazon card, you’ll get a 6% bonus on your redemption amount.

The Amazon option processes in one day, whereas it can take up to seven business days for the check to arrive.

I sold a gift card to Bass Pro Shops and chose to get an Amazon gift card. The transaction processed in less than one day and I used the gift card without any problems.

In-Store and Kiosk Exchanges

In addition to using the Cardpool website to sell your cards, you can go get cash through in-store partnerships and Cardpool kiosks. In-store options include grocery stores, banks, and department stores.

You can find a store or kiosk near you through by doing a quick search on the Cardpool site.

When I did a search, I found no kiosks near me but I did have two Target locations near me.

Both the in-store option and kiosk work the same way. You bring your gift card and your ID, Cardpool gives you an offer and, if you accept, you give them the card and they give you cash.

The drawback is that the prices you get in-person are going to be lower than what you get online.

Cardpool Guarantee

For up to one year after your gift card purchase, Cardpool guarantees your gift card will work. If it doesn’t the site promises to reimburse for the original amount you purchased.

The guarantee does not apply to gift cards at stores that went out of business or stopped their gift card program.

This guarantee benefits you because of the peace of mind it provides you with. Using a service like Cardpool could seem too good to be true—even I had my doubts when I tried it—so it benefits you to know your card is guaranteed for at least one year.

The Bottom Line

Cardpool’s marketplace is a simple, efficient place to buy gift cards or sell them so you can get cash.

Based on the analysis we did, we think this service is good for some but not for others:

Cardpool Is Good For:

  • You have an in-demand gift card you want to sell. The offers for your cards will be higher than what you’d get for cards from low-demand stores.

  • You need a quick way to exchange a gift card you don’t want. You can take a gift card you received as a present, sell it and get an Amazon gift card in less than a day.

  • You want something your gift-card store doesn’t offer. The fact that you can redeem your sold gift card for an Amazon gift card opens up all kinds of shopping choices your original gift card didn’t give you.

Cardpool Is Not Good For:

  • You want to sell a low-demand gift card. There’s a good chance that Cardpool’s offer for your low-demand gift card will be less than what you want and may not be worth selling.

  • You want the highest possible price for your gift card. While Cardpool is a convenient choice, it may not always be the most profitable one for you. If you have a high-demand gift card, you could try selling it via a local Facebook marketplace page or through a classifieds app like LetGo or Mercari.

Customer Reviews

Start your review of Cardpool:
  • 17 Customer Reviews
  • 18% Recommend This Company
1.7 out of 5
5 star: 11% 4 star: 5% 3 star: 0% 2 star: 5% 1 star: 76%

 Our Promise to You

To safeguard you and ensure helpfulness and relevance, our compliance team manually assess every customer review before it goes live.

We have a zero-tolerance policy for fake reviews, and companies cannot control or alter any reviews at any time.

Sort reviews by:

  • Worked OK

    • By V K.,
    • Sioux Falls, SD,
    • Apr 24, 2020
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    I sold them my Christopher & Banks gift card. It was a $25 gift card and I got about $16-$18 back for it. It has been a couple of months so it is hard for me to remember the exact amount. The whole process did take at least a month, I had opted for a paper check instead of an Amazon card. I did receive my check and deposited it with no issues.

    Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

  • Scam

    • By Don K.,
    • Sand Springs, OK,
    • Feb 20, 2020
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    Used their online service to buy my Bass Pro card at a discounted price. Followed their directions to the T and had no problem...but they took my card and never paid me...I complained many many times until they denied buying my card and suggested I make out a police report and ask Bass Pro about how it got stolen.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • So frustrated

    • By Lauren D.,
    • Los Angeles, CA,
    • Feb 12, 2020
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    I am so frustrated with this company. They have had my money for over a month with no communication or time frame on when they will process my order. I have sent 3 emails, have waited on the phone for 20 minutes, spoke to 2 "representatives" and no one can give me answers. They have no other contact information as well. SCAM!

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • Lack of customer service, communication, and follow through

    • By E F.,
    • Virginia,
    • Jan 8, 2020
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    After receiving recommendations and reading reviews about Cardpool, I decided to use their services to sell several gift cards I had not used. Navigating their site and submitting the cards was easy and seamless. However, after waiting for a month for a status report on the processing of the cards or a payment, I decided to contact the company. They use a separate site for customer service, which was also easy to navigate and use. Again, I waited for a month for a response, regularly checking my account on that site as well as the Cardpool site, and received none. Then, I contacted the company at the phone number on the site and was told by the individual who answered the phone that was the commercial department but that she would expedite my order. Several days following, when I checked my orders, I found that my order had been canceled and that one card I had mailed in was being returned although there was no reason provided as to why. The website affirms that no reason will be provided for orders canceled or cards returned. Interestingly, I found another company offering the same services that accepted the cards and sent me a check within a week of my order being placed. I would not recommend Cardpool.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • Cardpool SCAM SCAM SCAM!

    • By Ryan W.,
    • Cheyenne, WY,
    • Jun 25, 2019
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    I sold Cardpool a number of legitimate gift cards online.

    They refused every transaction, stole my balances, and sent me the following email.

    If you are naive enough to do business with Cardpool, you will likely receive this exact form email.:

    "Dear X,

    We recently received your gift card code transaction but our processing center encountered an issue while processing your cards.

    Our risk assessment team has determined that we aren't able to accept the transaction at this time. We have cancelled the transaction and are returning ownership of the gift cards to you. Unfortunately, we're not able to disclose any further specifics regarding this process.

    We apologize for any inconvenience to you.

    Best regards,

    Customer Support"

    SCAM! Scam!

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


    • By Murray T.,
    • Massachusetts,
    • Jun 20, 2019
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    I have a card which I received that has a zero balance. It should have a $25 balance. Tried to reach customer service by email and phone, NO RESPONSE, it has now been over a month. Stay away from Cardpool because you will get screwed.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • I'd rate them a 0 if I could!

    • By Kate F.,
    • Yakima, WA,
    • Jun 6, 2019
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    My debit card was stolen and someone charged 3 separate charges totally almost $2,000! I called while the charges were still pending, hoping I could get them to stop before they were actually processed. There is no hold option; only an option to leave your name and phone number and "they'll get back to you" because your business is so very important to them. I called and left 3 messages, I wrote through Facebook and 3 separate times I responded to their emails asking if my issue had been resolved. I didn't get one single reply to any of inquiries and the charges have now gone through. Absolutely horrible customer service. I will never use this company for anything!

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • No gift cards

    • By Manja M.,
    • Ohio,
    • May 1, 2019
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    I ordered two gift cards which I never received. I sent multiple emails with no response or refund. The order was placed the beginning of April, they said 7-10 business days, it's been three weeks.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • Cardpool is a scam! Beware!

    • By C B.,
    • Bay Area, CA,
    • Apr 10, 2019
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    I sold a $25 Papa John's gift card to this loser company on 1/06/2019. As of April 6th, 2019 have yet to receive the Amazon gift card they promised me. I have e-mailed five times over the past few months and always get an automated response saying they will get back to me in a few days, but they don't. I notified the BBB who attempted to contact the company but were unsuccessful. They probably honor a few transactions to keep the sham going, but they are flat out stealing from people. I don't buy the backlog story from a change of ownership at this point either. Cardpool knows perfectly well that they are playing a con game, which is why they won't respond to the BBB or the customers whom they've scammed.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • "In Review" gift cards - what to do

    • By Anna S.,
    • Wisconsin,
    • Feb 27, 2019
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    To anyone who sold gift cards to Cardpool and their payment is "In Review:" My order was "in review" for three weeks. I went ahead and sold my $250 Ticketmaster gift card number with Pin # to and got paid in one business day with no fee via PayPal. I called to check their customer service and got through to a friendly rep. CardCash is the real deal. Cardpool smells scammy. CardCash paid $10 less, but it was way worth it having that money securely and swiftly in my bank account. So if your transaction is "In Review" - go ahead and submit your Card and Pin #s elsewhere - and delete your Cardpool payment info and cancel your order!

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

  • Non existent company

    • By Sara P.,
    • Monterey, CA,
    • Feb 20, 2019
    • Verified Reviewer
    Overall Experience:

    Sold my $300 card to them on 2/7/19, was supposed to get my credit in 1-3 business days. Today is 2/15/19, never heard back from them. Called twice and left a message as no one picks up, and emailed three times. What a joke, must be a scam. Saw an article online about how they are under new ownership and cards are taking a lot longer to get processed. Lame.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Showing 1-11 of 17

Write a Review for Cardpool!

Share your experience to help others discover great products!

Write a Review
Cardpool Review: Is It Legit?