Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

Suppose to be nonstick. Wrong! Everything sticks to this pan. I have tried many times frying eggs and hash browns, etc., with and without oil and they stick no matter what. The one plus is that it is easy to clean after everything has stuck to the pan.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Unlike some of you, I never experience something that did not stick and I tried different levels of heat on my gas stove. I bought the 12.5 inch at Bed Bath & Beyond for the price of $29.99. Don't buy this product.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I am very sad that it does not live up to the standard of what is advertised. Everything sticks. I refuse to pay a $10 processing fee to send back the pan to tell me it sucks. I have the 12-inch frying pan and the 12-inch square pan. I used the square pan for the time to cook bacon. A BIG no-no. I have tried to use oil to re-sear the pans. NO LUCK. In the trash they go.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I don't want to give one star, but it is required to post this review. It is not worth one star!

This pan should be pulled from the market as it is FALSE advertisement! You waste money in this pan. It does nothing it says it will do! Food sticks during the first use. It does not wipe clean. Horrible JOKE being played on hard working people! Don't buy this product!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Completely false advertising in the infomercial, I'm not sure how human beings allow themselves to lie to each other on TV like this and it be legal...

I purchased it at Walmart for $30, I have used it 4 times.

I reheated Chinese food in the pan and it stuck like a crust, had to scrape it off. Also made ground lamb and BOY did that sticks, I had to soak the pan first before I cleaned it.

The pan has deep gashes in the distinct scrape marks on the pan, this was simply a metal fork - I used it because the pan advertised metal would not damage it. This is completely untrue.

What can anyone do about such a hoax like the Gotham Steel Pan? How do we elevate our complaints and actually do something tangible about this thievery in a legal form?

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

We purchased two sizes of these pans and at first, they were great. Within six months everything was sticking. We take really good care of our pans too. We hand wash and place rubber separators between the pans so they do not scratch when stacked.

We have old Teflon pans that have been used regularly for years and they don't stick like these Gotham Steel pans after only a couple of months.

We contacted the company and they said the only thing that they could do is have us mail the pans to them in the US for replacement. The cost of mailing them would be the same as purchasing new pans and we would be stuck with the same poor quality pans. When I spoke with them it was easy to hear that they really didn't care.

Do not buy Gotham Steel Pans!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

These pans worked for the first two uses, after that, food stuck to them while cooking like my other pans. They were easier to clean. I have been using them for 2 months now, so I am not throwing them out. Just very disappointed. When I called, the response was that they use them and they are great. I have had eggs burn as I tried to pry them from the pan (no, I did not use butter, oil, or spray). I thought that was the reason for buying these pans. Very very disappointed.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I wish I had read these reviews before I wasted my money. Does not work as advertised. Bought it yesterday, made simple sunny side up eggs. Cooked on a flame so low, you could barely see it. They still stuck and by the time I scraped them out of the pan, they were scrambled. Going back to my old non stick pans. This one may become a door stop. Would not recommend to anyone.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The claims are false. After 2 uses, everything sticks to it. Impossible to clean. Don't walk away from their offer, run!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I ordered this product because our current frying pan needed replacing and it sounded like this would be a great replacement. Unfortunately everything sticks to it. We tried to make eggs and omelets with terrible results. I am returning mine today! Based upon my experience these do not work as advertised.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased 4 of these pans 2 were for wedding gift and 2 for me. Both pans worked as advertised for about the first 8 times of use then everything stuck to them. It didn't matter what you cooked and I had to add some oil so that the food would not stick. I also noticed that even though I cooked on low-med heat, the bottom of the pan became discolored and looked like coating was coming off and it would not come clean with anything I used. In my opinion, these are no better than a good non stick pan.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend