Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

I first used the Gotham Steel pan while visiting family and loved it. Food will stick IF YOU USE COOKING SPRAY, which builds up a residue on the pan after a few times of using it. This is probably the reason why some people have experienced food sticking. It is sticking to the residue, not to the pan. The paper insert that comes with the pan does state not to use cooking spray.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

Will I ever learn not to buy something I see on an info? Eggs stuck to this pan the very first time I used it. I delayed using metal utensils for a while then I thought I could turn eggs easier with my metal spatula, so I used it very carefully making sure not to dig in. I noticed a few days later there was a deep scratch in the pan and then to add insult to injury the bottom of the pan rounded. So I have a ceramic cooktop and this pan spins around and sits uneven now. Don't waste your money.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Received it in May, worked good for 3-4 dishes. Now pan starting to stick, burns food while cooking. Tiny black spots on the bottom that won't come out.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I went strictly by manufacturer's instructions, never used more than mid heat setting. Pan was great, then after a few months of use, food started sticking. There is a slight discoloration where sticking occurs. Ads show hitting pan with a blow torch, and I never used more than mid setting on a stove, no spray oil, etc. Looks like technology has not yet reached the point where it can be used long term under normal conditions. Back to the R&D lab guys.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought this pan at Walmart and it's going right back. It was $19.99, and I didn't have to deal with ordering online or S&H, so I gave it a try.

I just simmered some onions and peppers on very low heat while making spaghetti sauce. I noticed some minor scorching on the pan, but it didn't burn my food. Then, when I went to wash it by hand, I noticed it didn't wipe off as easily as it did in the commercial.

I washed it in warm soapy water and let it dry. Then I went to clean my stove top. What the heck? I now have silver rings on my glass stove top that weren't there before - and I can't get them off!

I was careful to keep all the packaging and paperwork that came with the pan and noticed that there's an Arbitration Agreement included. I read it and it claims that by purchasing this pan you waive all rights to a jury trial or a class action lawsuit. Gee, I wonder why they felt that was necessary to include? Buyer beware!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I received the Gotham pan as a gift and was so excited. I used it twice and my eggs completely stuck to the frying pan. I even took a picture because I could not believe it.

Brand new definitely did not work, and I would definitely not recommend wasting your money!

A very unhappy customer.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased this item at my local Walmart and for the first month it worked great. Then in the second month, it started to stick. I am now four months in, and now it sticks with everything and doesn't even clean good anymore.

I have gone back to my old cast iron fry pan.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Well, first off, I ordered the 7-piece Gotham cookware set through Groupon. I only chose the cookware because the item I had purchased (golf tee times coupon) had expired and it seemed like a fair deal for the price. I even had to pay a little extra because my existing coupon was a bit short. Anyway. When I received the item, apparently the recipe/cook book was missing. I then look at the shipping receipt and it states a six piece set, but the box clearly states a 7-piece set. So I try contacting customer service online for Gotham, and all you get is "order", " order", "order".

The cookware itself, EVERYTHING STICKS if you don't use butter or oil. At least that's what my pans do. I can't get an egg or egg whites to slide out like they show unless I use some type of fat. They suggest not using PAM or sprays because they say it will discolor the pans. I definitely can't get popcorn to pop before it burns the kernels. In my case, they are junk/garbage. Buyer beware.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought this pan just before Christmas of 2016. It is April, and the food in the pan sticks like crazy. It is impossible to clean up easily. My cast iron is more nonstick than this pan. Waste of money.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased this Ggotham Steel Pan after seeing the amazing commercial for its nonstick abilities, and it can go into a hot oven and won't scratch! At first, I cooked eggs without oil, and they slid out of the pan but had a funny plastic texture on the bottom. Then I tried meat without oil in the oven, and the meat stuck and left marks on the inside of the pan. So now I always use oil in the pan before I add anything or the food sticks so bad and it is so hard to clean.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I was really excited to try my new nonstick pan. I was totally disappointed in its performance. The first couple of times it was fine, and then EVERYTHING sticks, and it is a pain to clean. NO, I would not recommend this to my enemies!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend