Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

It worked like advertised on TV the first time (with eggs). The second time, I became concerned, it was sticking. The third time, the eggs were sticking a bit even with oil, the fourth use revealed the truth, the product must be covered with a magic film that only works for a short period before wearing away. By then, most people have lost the receipt or worse, if they purchased online, they don't want to go through the return process.

I just returned the junk to Walmart where I purchased it (I had kept my receipt, thank heaven).

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The first week was fab, I was so impressed that I threw out my heavy Raymond Blanco Analon Stainless steel pan. What a mistake, because now everything sticks to my new pan, even a simple fried egg is known in our house as a "welded-on" egg. Burgers left a perfect burnt impression that I couldn't scrub off.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased the Gotham Steel cookie tray on a "2 for 1" offer. I have used these to bake cookies and I love them. My oatmeal raisin cookies would start sticking on my other non-stick trays after a number of batches in the oven. Nothing sticks to these trays.

They are also easy to wash by hand (I don’t put them in the dishwasher).

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

Terrible product, very dissatisfied. It does not cook bacon crispy, clean up is not good at all, oil from bacon sticks to the bottom of the pan, too small; not worth the money at all. I hope no one wasted their money or time ordering this bacon pan. I purchased one for myself and one for my father and stepmother for Christmas, and now another gift will differently have to be bought.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Gotham Steel is NOT nonstick. My 3-quart pan burned syrup and I took the finish off getting it off. It stuck like concrete. I've been on the phone with the company for 18 minutes. No resolve at all. The rep was nice but had no options.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I first purchased two of the smaller frying pans because I thought they were beautiful. I loved the color and style. I was a little skeptical at first about not having to use oil or butter to cook with. I do my best to promote a healthier way of eating by cooking with less oils and fats, and this product would be awesome if it actually worked. I couldn't wait to try cooking in them.

My first test was cooking an egg. Love at first sight. Eggs, cheese, refried beans...love, love, love this product. The stay cool handles are also a plus. Since my first purchase, I have now acquired the largest to the smallest of all of their fry pans (a total of six I believe), as well as their square skillet, which is great for pancakes, gooey stuffed french toast, and more.

Exceptionally easy cleaning and beautiful to look at. I am not sure if I have purchased all of their products, but I will certainly keep looking for it as well as recommending this amazing product to friends and family.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

Save your cash; this is a piece of junk. The pan works very well if you want things to stick. Better than glue. I have washed and tried to use is several times and the food sticks even better than before. Absolute scam. And there is no humans to respond to getting a refund. Just a recording. You eventually give up and place the pan where it belongs - in the garbage.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I received this product as a Christmas gift and was very excited to use it. The first time I used it, it seemed to be alright, but it didn't exactly seem to be as portrayed in the commercials. The more I used it the worse it got. I think it is the worst pan I have ever used. I can't fry anything in it without it sticking.

I really think this is a serious case of consumer fraud and misleading the public. I am currently trying to find a way to return it, but am also finding this to be very difficult, and I am not surprised that this is so difficult as the product itself is a piece of garbage. I hope this message goes to the proper person that can reimburse me the $30.00 that this piece of crap cost.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased the 12.5" frying pan. Seemed to cook and clean up easily at first. I followed the directions and never used non-stick cooking sprays. Now food burns very easily, and it's impossible to clean the pan regardless of soaking and scrubbing. Worthless! I'm requesting a refund from Bed Bath & Beyond.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

I purchased the large griddle and am very disappointed with this product. It warped the first time I used it. Both the bacon and hamburgers stuck. The pan has discolored and is hard to clean.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The pan works great at first, but after using it for about a month, it does not work anymore. Everything will stick to it. I have tried looking for the warranty online, and I could not find it. I will not recommend this pot to anyone that cooks every day.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend