Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

I agree with all the other reviews. Any Teflon pan in my kitchen works better. Almost all food sticks to the Gotham Steele pans. I just fried an egg in one, and even with oil in the pan, my egg stuck like glue. We bought an entire set, and each pan may have worked the first time or two using them, but after that they were worthless. This is definitely a scam! Can I give it zero stars?

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

These pans don't do anything as advertised and I have tried several. Everything WILL stick. The worse thing is that they are impossible to clean. They get a build up that I have never experienced before. I have thrown all of them away because I would have to take a magic eraser sponge to get the residue off. I know they would say I destroyed the finish, but it literally was the only way to clean them. Save your money. This is totally a scam.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The pan began to quit releasing food in an acceptable fashion. This started after less than one month of limited service. Other Gotham Steel pans followed suit shortly afterward.

Very disappointing. Advised friends not to purchase.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Garbage, that’s where it ended up. Does not perform as advertised. Food sticks to the pan and is hard to clean. A waste of money as we had to throw it out. I did not use any oils or butter as directed.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I called customer service about the sticking pan, and I was told to pay $9.95 for the replacement. The pan lasted four months. Their customer service told how to clean pan, but after cleaning the pan, it suck even worse. The pan is definitely not as advertised.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

These are the worst cooking pots and pans I ever bought and used! They not only stick but in some cases, they are very dangerous. Very dissatisfied and disappointed, as I bought several sizes. The store offered to have me return them but that is too much drama! I bought them online, and the research and calls just discouraged me. I bought a new cast iron dutch casserole and a skillet, they work just fine, I grew up using them.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I have had this pan set for less than a year. They were ok the first time I used them, then they just got worse every time thereafter. They are absolutely not what they say they are. No butter or oil my hiney! Eggs, I need to use at least a tablespoon of oil or butter and that doesn’t even make them slide around like in the infomercial. I’ve never been able to get anything to not stick to these! The dollar store shouldn’t accept them. So if you have bought these, or are still going to because you don’t believe me, then don’t be dumb like I was, fill out your warranty! Every pan in the set is garbage!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Months ago, I ordered two pans and one lid. Months later, after receiving the pans, I inquired about the lid and was advised the lids were all canceled because they're not making them anymore. No customers were notified, and they refused to send a return label for the pans, and I was advised if returned, no refund because it has been too long.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Everything advertised about this pan is a lie, it sticks, it burns, and it scratches. I own the pan and the pan is ready for the trash. All advertisements are a lie. The pan lasted me two months. I do not recommend anyone to purchase this pan, it's a waste of money. I hated it.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought these pans about a year ago. After a few months everything started to stick a little bit, but now everything sticks all over the pans. Don't waste your hard earned money. Buy a cheap pan from Canadian Tire or Walmart for $9.99 when they are on sale. You won't feel bad when you have to toss it.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I tried to fry an egg in the pan and it stuck like crazy. My husband also bought me the griddle. I tried cooking Canadian bacon on it. What a disaster. Not only did it stick, there is still residue on the pan that I can't clean off. I am so disappointed.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend