Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

I'm looking for the perfect "no hands" over medium, egg flipping pan I can find. My five year old scratched up Teflon pan was no longer working as well as it used to, meaning eggs didn't slide around as well as they used to.

This pan may as well be a dry, unseasoned iron skillet. These eggs stick instantly, low heat, high heat, medium heat on an expensive gas stove.

Oil heats up faster than you can crack an egg into it, they stick terribly with oil. They seem to do ok with a heavy dousing of non-stick spray, but that makes the eggs taste weird and besides, that defeats the purpose, right.

The worst pan I've ever used for eggs! Worst no stick surface I've ever used in 40 years of cooking.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Seen the pan on TV so I bought one. Next morning broke two eggs in the pan to cook, had to scrape them out of pan. Bought at Wal-mart. Stay away from these pans.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I was so disappointed with the Gotham Copper Skillet. After the second use, everything cooked in it stuck, even with oil or Pam Spray. Save your money and don't buy. The skillet was only used by me, a senior citizen and was wiped out at first but now has to be hand washed. Wish I had seen this site before I purchased.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I ordered the one small pan and then another complimentary pan. The automatic phone order constantly added advertisements, which was very annoying, but not as annoying when my $19.99 plus shipping order came to over $100. I called the next day to cancel, only to learn that I was not in the system. Good, I thought, my hang up on them was acknowledged. No, it is already on its way with no way to cancel. I never received that email with my confirmation number. My advice. Do not place orders with them.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I watched the ad on TV. I actually bought one at Giant Tiger store. I liked the pan however. They advertise "millions" sold. So I ordered the complete set from Gotham.ca too. I went to check on order and saw that none of the products were in stock.

So I called the customer service number, and they won't have stock until "maybe" the end of the first week of October.

I placed an order beginning of September which I was also charged the full 361.00 for. The lady on phone said, “you won't be charged for your order”. I told her I've already been charged. She got a little rude and said, “Oh, within in 24 hours that charge will come back.” If they advertise that "millions sold", why are they out of stock?

Let's see when I get my money back. Maybe they shouldn't sell a product they don't have. So the customer has to wait for them to get product (a month), then wait for another how long before they finally receive the product. Sketchy.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

My dad bought this pan because he's had a stroke and only has use of one hand. He figured it was the perfect pan to meet his needs. Well it did for about the first 8-10 times he used it. After that all it does is stick. So expensive for such a poorly made frying pan. False advertising and deceiving to those consumers that are vulnerable.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The indestructible pan is barely 3 months old and it is scratching. This pan is a scam.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Everything sticks to this pan.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

First of all, they advertise the pan to be 9 1/2" in diameter. It isn't. It's 9 3/8" and they know it, so why the lie?

Secondly and mainly: During about a month of light usage, the pan worked as advertised but then food began to stick to the bottom after each use. Now it's just another fry pan that has food stuck to the bottom of. Every one of these lying pricks should be nailed in a class action lawsuit.

Let's see if you post this one. I'm betting that you won't.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Nonstick my butt. I cooked 4 eggs the 1st time using them. Didn't use any spray or butter or oil. NOTHING. I had to scrape the eggs out of the pan. Nonstick? The next time I used spray and it was fine. But on all my other pans, if I sprayed them 1st, they were fine too. So why should I pay a price for these when they are not any better than any other pan? Save your money. What a joke. Another TV SCAM.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought this Gotham Pan at Walmart. After purchasing it, and prior to using the frying pan, my wife checked the reviews and she pointed out that there were many bad reviews. She almost took the pan back before trying it, however, she decided to give it a try and the Gotham Pan worked great! So our review is positive and we are happy with this product.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend