Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

I'm highly disappointed with this garbage. Now I'm stuck with them and I bought the whole set. It only took a month and they scratched. I wish I could get my money back to buy a different set, but the money back guarantee doesn't go for people who buy them at Walmart. Don't waste your money because there is no money back guarantee.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought a Gotham pan at Canadian Tire in Victoria, British Columbia, and it worked great the first few times. After about ten uses it is useless. Everything sticks to it. Even poached eggs stick! Today was the final straw and into the steel recycle bin it goes. I am wondering if something screws up if you overheat it? I won't be buying another one. Back to my good old favorite cast iron pan.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The 11-inch fry pan got a chip in it, and now some food is sticking to it. So much for their warranty; what a ripoff. I am not happy with their product. Seems to me that it's false advertising.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased frying pans from Showcase, and they were a gift for my wife, which we only opened and used two months later. That is when we realized that the frying pans did not work the way they said they would; everything sticks on the small pan and bringer pan.

I called Showcase on this, and they do not warranty this.

So think before buying, as the product is not what they are saying it actually does. I also bought pots that work fine. In fact, I bought the whole set for my wife, including the deep dish pan, which also sticks.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The commercials are showing a different product. My Gotham steel pan burnt eggs and it stuck. I tried with and without butter and it sticks every time and it's not easy to clean. Garbage product. I'd post a picture and video if I could to show how crappy this is.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I have an 11-inch Gotham Steel Pan. I ordered it from a catalog, but I have to air my frustration! Everything sticks, and now it starts to pit in the center of the pan. There is no way for me to replace the pan, so I lost the $19.95.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought this pan just before Christmas of 2016. It is April, and the food in the pan sticks like crazy. It is impossible to clean up easily. My cast iron is more nonstick than this pan. Waste of money.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Well, first off, I ordered the 7-piece Gotham cookware set through Groupon. I only chose the cookware because the item I had purchased (golf tee times coupon) had expired and it seemed like a fair deal for the price. I even had to pay a little extra because my existing coupon was a bit short. Anyway. When I received the item, apparently the recipe/cook book was missing. I then look at the shipping receipt and it states a six piece set, but the box clearly states a 7-piece set. So I try contacting customer service online for Gotham, and all you get is "order", " order", "order".

The cookware itself, EVERYTHING STICKS if you don't use butter or oil. At least that's what my pans do. I can't get an egg or egg whites to slide out like they show unless I use some type of fat. They suggest not using PAM or sprays because they say it will discolor the pans. I definitely can't get popcorn to pop before it burns the kernels. In my case, they are junk/garbage. Buyer beware.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I am very sad that it does not live up to the standard of what is advertised. Everything sticks. I refuse to pay a $10 processing fee to send back the pan to tell me it sucks. I have the 12-inch frying pan and the 12-inch square pan. I used the square pan for the time to cook bacon. A BIG no-no. I have tried to use oil to re-sear the pans. NO LUCK. In the trash they go.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased these pans from Canadian Tire, and although they were good for the first month or two, they are NOT what they claim to be now. Now when I cook with them, everything sticks. Even when I make basic scrambled eggs, I have to soak the pan and SCRUB the pan to get food off. I'm extremely DISAPPOINTED with these pans now. How do I get my money back?

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I love the nonstick aspect of the pan, but I've already had to replace one and need to replace this one (originally purchased on March 8, 2017) as well because it has scratches on the surface. I rarely use metal utensils on the pan, and I certainly am not abusing it. I even hand wash it.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend