Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

At first, the pan worked great. Eggs and anything else was sliding off without a spatula. I was so excited I threw away my regular non-stick skillet. After about 10 uses, stuff was sticking! I was shocked. I actually have to practically scrape the food off, even if I used oil. I no longer have the order number because the effect lasted just long enough to then throw that paperwork away. I wonder if there's anything that can be done to bring back the non-stick effect?

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased one of these pans as a gift for my son as he was trying to lose some weight. I thought that without having to use butter or any kind of oil, it would be perfect for him. But to my surprise, it did not work as advertised. The eggs stuck to the pan and were not as easy to wipe out either. I will never purchase another one of these pans. Definitely false advertising!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I was so excited my husband bought me two grill skillets. I've been wanting them so long and am finally getting not one, but two. I couldn't wait to get home to try them. He bought them for our anniversary.

I fried two eggs on medium heat with NO OIL OR BUTTER. And they stuck to the pan a little and tasted as dry as a bone.

I wiped the skillet clean very carefully, taking pride in my new gift. The next time the eggs stuck was worse than before.

Now I have new pans that don't hold up. And we bought them from a store far away. So I go to get on the website, and all you can do is order.

I'm so disappointed. I paid all that hard-earned money for the pans to hang on the wall.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

This Gotham non-stick pan should be called sure-stick! A total waste of money. Everything I cooked in it stuck! It ruined my fresh yard eggs. They should be charged with false advertisement!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased an entire set for my wife. Within two weeks they were unusable. If there was a review for negative ten, that is what I would give them. Nothing but an advertising sham.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought two fry pans at Frey's in Wilsonville, Oregon. We brought the pans home. I washed them in hot soapy water. I dried the pans and I proceeded to prepare an egg sandwich. I place the pan on the burner and turned it on at a medium-low heat. I cracked the egg into the pan. The egg stuck! It was scrambled by the time I got it out of the pan. In short, this pan doesn't work as advertised. I feel their TV ad is a fraud!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

It is a "pretty pan," but that is the end of its redeeming qualities. I experiment, try new things and it is always an adventure, which means the outcome is not assured.

My experiment with buying a Gotham Steel fry pan off a television commercial was a bust. It started out very slippery, but within a very short time, the darn thing sticks to food, even with bacon fat in it. We have been very careful not to overheat the pan, but it just didn't matter. The non-stick quality of the pan degraded over a month of using the pan. Our son put a scratch in it, so it is not as tough as they purport. either.

I would not recommend this pan to anyone. It is a waste of resources. As with all experiments, I learned something; the Gotham pan sucks and beware of slick television commercials, so it was an instructive failure.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The pan sticks even on fried eggs. It sticks to everything. I have a friend who has a restaurant. He threw them out. I hate the commercial because it is all orchestrated and time lapsed. It is an insult to anyone with half a brain.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

These pans are a waste of money. The first two times I cooked eggs in them, and they were just fine. I took excellent care of them and then they went downhill. Now, everything STICKS! How come?

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

This pan warped the very first time I used it, or it may have been warped when I bought it. I never used a high heat so it should not be warped. I quit using it and took it out of my cupboard completely. I would definitely not buy another product like this.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Everything started sticking after the first use, and there was a small, deep cut on the pan's surface. I used it the last time this morning, and it's going in the trash! Never again will I use it or buy anything else Gotham!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend