Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

These pans worked well for a few months, however, quickly lost the nonstick that they promoted.

I cooked dumplings in these pans and they totally stuck and fell apart.

I won’t buy them again. I'd rather buy a good nonstick pan that lasts.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought my set at Bed Bath & Beyond here in Kamloops, and I like the pots and pans well enough, but I am not happy with the handles/lids on them. I burned the palm my right hand by lifting the frying pan and found the handles too narrow to grip safely.

I suggest that they either warn shoppers to use protection when lifting the lids or handles on their pans or perhaps coating them with a heat-resistant surface.

I went back to Bed Bath & Beyond and purchased a silicone gripper, but it doesn't work very well either as the handles are too thin to grip properly, and it was an added expense that did not help the problem.

I would tell others about this product but would warn them to be careful when lifting the lids or picking up the pots and to use pot holders when doing so.

I hope you find my input helpful.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

My husband purchased the Gotham Steel square pan as a Christmas gift for me (December 2017). I watched the commercials and noticed a metal spatula and metal tongs were being used. I read the warranty info enclosed in the box, and their commercial is misleading since the info states to NOT use metal inside the pan. I've treated my pan like fine china and yet I am seeing scratches inside the pan, and now the coating both inside and out is beginning to flake off! My pan is less than three months old. I love how easily it cleans and that nothing sticks, but it won't be long before the pan is useless due to the coating coming off. Needless to say, I'm very disappointed.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

We bought a set of these pans. When we first used them, we loved them! An egg would literally slide out of the pan as we were serving it. We have had them a little over a year, and now that is no longer the case. In fact, everything sticks to the point that we have to soak them to get them clean, even if we have used butter or olive oil. We are using a gas range, and the coating on the bottom of the pans has worn off considerably. I DO NOT like them!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I have a good set of stainless cookware but thought I would try this pan for eggs only. I like my eggs poached rather than fried. Who would have ever expected that you would have to spray it with nonstick spray before poaching? Everything sticks to this. I tried to make an omelet for breakfast this morning, and it was disastrous. I had to start all over again but this time I sprayed it. I prefer to use my stainless over this because I have to spray no matter what and stainless is probably less toxic than these pans.

Not a good product. I couldn't find an email address to email them, but from what I have read they don't respond anyway. Going to trash to My Treasure Sale. Maybe they'll have better luck.

The number on the handle - 6121A.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased the pan about three months ago and have decided the commercials aren't truthful. Everything sticks to them when cooking; eggs, meat, you name it, they all stick to the bottom. Cleaning them isn't a breeze either.

I would not recommend buying because in a very short time you will be disappointed.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

When I first received my Gotham Steel skillet, I was elated. It was pretty easy to clean with just a paper towel. A little harder to clean on the inside where the handle attached. We use it basically for cooking eggs, mainly scrambled, although I have cooked steak and hamburger. That is about it. I have only had it about five months, and it is all scratched up on the bottom, and I can no longer clean it without immersing in soap and water. I would rate it a two at best. I loved it for the first month, but all downhill after that.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I tried to fry an egg in the pan and it stuck like crazy. My husband also bought me the griddle. I tried cooking Canadian bacon on it. What a disaster. Not only did it stick, there is still residue on the pan that I can't clean off. I am so disappointed.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought one of those pans on Amazon and it definitely does not work, all my food sticks to the pan. I have to scrub it out every time I am finished with it. I will not buy one of these again.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I was very disappointed in this product. It doesn't do what it claims to do. The only way things don't stick is if the heat setting is on low. I have not cooked on high with these pans. I followed all the instructions and things started sticking after the second use. To send them back before time runs out is such a hassle, you pay for shipping back to them, you don't get your shipping back. They should be ashamed of such false advertising! I wish I would have read some reviews before buying these pans, which I usually do.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

My stepdaughter treated me to a set for Christmas. I was disappointed with the larger pan. Food started to stick and burn. Now even eggs burn. I am a private chef. I do not abuse the pan. I am very disappointed. I won’t do that again!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend