Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

I bought these pans and found out they will not work with an induction cooktop. Then yesterday I was using the glass 28cm lid with another pan on the cooktop, cooking a casserole on a medium heat and it IMPLODED!

I would not recommend them to anyone.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I guess it's true, don't believe everything you see.

This is the worst pan I have ever bought. Everything sticks to it. At first, it was so easy to clean and after a couple of uses, everything sticks and it's hard to clean.

This pan is a WASTE OF MONEY and is the WORST thing I have ever bought. I wish I could return it and get my money back. But I guess you live and learn. Don't buy one.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I ordered the Gotham Steel Pans through Amazon, and because I have Amazon Prime, I got it in two days. I bought the 12.5 inch for $49.95, with free shipping. I made fajitas with no oil, and they came out wonderfully and didn't stick at all! I've only used once so far, but I really thought it was fantastic.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

Normally I do not write reviews. We ordered the one 9-inch pan and my wife fell in love the pan. She was so amazed that she cooked an omelet in the pan with no oil or butter and the egg nor the cheese stuck even a little. She has since tried other ingredients that would normally stick and nothing. Then all you need to do is take a wet rag and wipe out the pan and it is clean. So naturally she had to have the whole set, with Lids. These are for once a product that is worth buying and does as advertised 100%.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

I have several of Gotham Steel's cookware and my large frying pan SUCKS. Doesn't matter what heat setting, everything STICKS. Their website has no CONTACT US page anywhere so I can PITCH a complaint. I will never buy again. I will choose a different brand next time.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Excellent product at a fair price. My mother bought me one and I fried two eggs over medium heat and was amazed. I won't be touching the cooking surface with metal regardless of claims that you can. I think this pan will last a lot of years.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

I've had this pan for only a month. It is NOT WORTH $19.99 plus tax. In fact, I wouldn't have wasted my very limited income on this crap. It is NOT NON-STICK for eggs. It scratches easily, even with just a spatula! I'm ashamed, that at the age of 57, I actually believed the advertising for this. Never again. Don't waste your money.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I am sorry to say that I had the most horrific experience with the Gotham Steel Pan. Although, I found items to burn and stick and required scraping when using no fat, that is not my issue.

After about 15 uses, a rivet exploded off the pan. It was the equivalent of a bomb. I am not exaggerating in the least. I had no idea what had happened, but knew that something whooshed by me. The noise was so loud that I had to check to see if my stove exploded as I was unsure of what happened. My ears were not right for the whole day. I seriously wondered if my eardrum was punctured. I had ringing in the ear until the next day. Finally, I connected the dots and found the rivet from the handle had blown across the room. It is the closest thing I can imagine to a gun shot.

I am not sure how the company will handle this and I am mostly wanting to warn other consumers. Had this hit me in the eye, or even worse, if my grandchildren were there, I shudder to think what could have occurred.

I called the Consumer Protection Agency and asked how they handle an occurrence of this nature. They will have me filled out forms and collect the data and if enough complaints happen, then action would be taken. If one person loses an eye, that is one too many.

I have been cooking for 40 years and still have some of the same pans. NEVER have I had to worry about a rivet blowing off of the pan.

I can only say, be very careful if you choose to use this item. I will contact the company, who has a lot of litigation rules in their flyer saying, “You waive the right to…”, but honestly my true concern is safety.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

The pan I got was wrapped on the bottom and did not sit flat on my cook top. The non-stick feature lasted about 3 months. A disappointment.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I watched the ad on TV. I actually bought one at Giant Tiger store. I liked the pan however. They advertise "millions" sold. So I ordered the complete set from Gotham.ca too. I went to check on order and saw that none of the products were in stock.

So I called the customer service number, and they won't have stock until "maybe" the end of the first week of October.

I placed an order beginning of September which I was also charged the full 361.00 for. The lady on phone said, “you won't be charged for your order”. I told her I've already been charged. She got a little rude and said, “Oh, within in 24 hours that charge will come back.” If they advertise that "millions sold", why are they out of stock?

Let's see when I get my money back. Maybe they shouldn't sell a product they don't have. So the customer has to wait for them to get product (a month), then wait for another how long before they finally receive the product. Sketchy.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I spoke to Joanne in Customer Service and she was so rude! She told me that they would not take back my pans because they did not have my pans - she did, BJs has your money!

BACON STICKS IN THESE PANS and, they have horrible customer service! BE WARNED!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend