Gotham Steel Pans Reviews

These pans are absolutely my favorite. I only bought one and have used it for six months, and I am so happy that I’m going to purchase a full set. Donate my old ones to the food basket. I can literally use this one pan multiple times cooking a meal quickly and perfect temp across the entire surface, clean in seconds and back on the stove for the next portion. Awesome!

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

Gotham Steel at 400 RETURNS Road, Wallingford, CT is really Fosdick Fulfillment Corporation (a miniature Amazon knock off) at 26 Barnes Industrial Park N, Wallingford, CT 06492.

Now, the cookware is ok, and if you want aluminum, it is great. I specifically wanted GOTHAM STEEL stainless titanium 1806D, which this is not.

So far, no fault. Began to check out returns and reorder the good stuff, hopefully with this same supplier. NOT!

Can only return to the fake address above and you will be charged for shipping and you might get a refund after 30-60 days.

Just be careful with this supplier!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

It worked for 3 days until food started sticking to the pan, each time it was used it got worse. Definitely not as advertised, poor quality, just not worth the investment. Do yourself a favor and don't waste your money on this product.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought two frying pans and one pot with the top that closes for draining. I used my mixer to do mashed potatoes in the pot like advertised...the side and bottom of the pot are now so scratched I do not want to use it again because of the coating that might get into my food. The two pans I bought also are so scratched I cannot use them. They are so much worse than any other pan I have used for scratching! I have many pictures, but unfortunately, there's no place to insert them.

Don't waste your money...this is a scam.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought the Gotham Steel Pan on November 17, 2018. Washed ONLY with a cloth and soap. Never put in the dishwasher (despite the fact that it is supposed to be safe to do so). Used ONLY rubber spatula. By the end of December 2018, everything was sticking to the pan. Left burn marks which would not come out. VERY false advertising. Would NEVER purchase again. Shame on you.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

Worst pots and pans I have ever bought. Two weeks after I bought them food started sticking, hard to clean, the coloring started coming off. Nicks and scratches. Waste of money, wish I had read reviews before I bought. My cheap pans work better than these pans. Would not recommend to anyone!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

This product DID NOT meet my expectations!

This POS is a waste of money. It will scratch and food will stick. It only took about 3 days for food to stick. It scratched right away. I want my hard-earned money back!

Heck no to recommending this scam of a product. I wish I could share a photo so others can see how this product has failed to meet my expectations.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I purchased my Gotham Steel (took advantage of the buy one get one) and received them in December 2018. I first used the pan I kept (gave the other one to my son) to cook fresh tortillas a few weeks ago. After the first tortilla stuck to the pan, I subsequently started using nonstick cooking spray - and the spray itself is now permanently stuck to the pan. I have tried soaking overnight, to no avail. I still use it, but EVERYTHING sticks on it - egg, meat I am trying to brown, EVERYTHING. I am happy to send a picture of it, but I've currently got it soaking to get rid of last night's stir fry remnants that are stuck on it.

Trying to find out how I can get my money back. This has been a total waste of money, and now time spent trying to clean it up to be useable. I want to return the pan so that the manufacturer can see for themselves how bad the pan they sent me truly is. I subsequently went out and bought two copper frying pans from Target and they are just fine and don't stick at all for the same uses. It was only this product that failed to work as advertised.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

One of the Gotham frying pans I purchased (two for price of one) was given to a friend who wanted to try it. Several days later, the largest wildfire in CA history struck our town of Paradise, CA and decimated most of the homes, including the one of my friend. Yesterday, I went by my friend's trailer (yes, we are all living in trailers) to give her my other pan and discovered they had located the pan in the debris. The outside was now white and the inside looked like it had sand stuck to it. Upon cleaning it up, the inside returned to the original slick surface but the outside remained white. I tried to reach Gotham Steel to let them know, but no phone number I called would let me through.

Just thought the world would like to know the pans are made to withstand incredible heat!

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend

After watching the infomercial I bought the 24" frying pan. I was and am extremely disappointed with the product. I read and followed the instructions that came with it. The first time I used it I cooked eggs. The ad showed the eggs sliding around the pan effortlessly. That didn't happen. They instantly stuck to the pan. I tried all types of food in the pan too. All of them stuck! This is a scam! Do not waste your money!

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend

After a short while, the pans are useless. Everything sticks even if you never used oil or any scratchy material. Worth only throwing away. They are not interested in warranty, I did speak to them but they asked if wanted other products and would not listen to the complaint.

Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend