I purchased the City Lips product, thinking the first three were a variety of colors, and ordered the second "set of 3" and ALL SIX came in clear. I would have preferred to have some colors in that many - but since I got all clear, I will probably share some of them with close friends. I was my mistake, so I'm NOT blaming City Lips - and their product DOES make my lips feel silky smooth.
Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend