I have been using City Lips (clear) for about a week and a few days. I use it daily throughout the whole day. I am a smoker and have those black lines on my lips. I will say that since I have been using City Lips, I have noticed my black lines becoming less visible (still there of course) and my lips are starting to look my healthier and pink. My lips also feel very moisturized. I have ordered another tube in hopes of seeing even more progress as I continue using. The only “bad” thing is I do not think there is enough lip gloss in one tube.
Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend