I'm writing this in January of 2017 but have been using Tatcha for at least two full years.
I have found no fake ingredients or hiding of any product content. In fact, they are pretty straightforward in their marketing. A fair amount of their products are fragrance-free on their own, while others have a natural fragrance.
They are expanding, and the hits keep coming. I really like this line! The rice exfoliant comes in 4 colors or skin types, and the cleansing oil is amazing. As far as Indigo, yes they use real indigo in that part of their line, and it really takes away redness and calms problem skin down. Even better is that all of their Indigo products are a beautiful blue hue that's natural.
They don't make too good to be true statements! Just well organized, good ingredients, and an all around experience. I certainly have my Tatcha favorites but have tried everything. Remember, not every single product or line will work for every single person.
Visit them on your own and have fun!
This was my recent order: Indigo hand lotion, Indigo body creme, new hand made camellia-based bars, pore perfecting water gel moisturizer, luminous memory serum concentrate & their beauty oil.
Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend