I've been a Gwynnie Bee subscriber for several years. I love the breadth of choices (labels, styles) and the speed of shipping when I return an item. I also much prefer closeting items myself. I tried one of the curated box services, and in spite of very clear answers like "never send dresses or skirts," I regularly received boxes containing those items.
Recently, as I started losing weight, I realized a huge added value to being a Gwynnie Bee subscriber. I've been able to progressively adjust the sizes down and try, not buy, as I continue to lose.
Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend