Proactiv+ Review: All You Need to Know

By Lydia Noyes
HighYa Staff
Updated on: Feb 29, 2020

Far from being merely a problem for adolescents, an estimated 50 million American adults deal with breakouts every year, making acne treatment a $1.2 billion industry.

Proactiv+ is a daily treatment for mild to moderate acne designed to fight the signs of breakouts with prescription-strength ingredients that go directly into your pores for deeper cleansing powers.

Since the company’s start in 1995, Proactiv claims to have helped more than 20 million people with their skin problems and has become the #1 acne brand in America.

The Proactiv+ line consists of three products—an exfoliator, a pore targeting treatment, and a hydrator—that work together to clear up hormonal breakouts and adult acne for men and women.

This product line is not recommended for anyone with severe cystic or nodular acne.

How does Proactiv+ compare to other acne treatments? Should you commit to using it long-term? Learn from our analysis what your best path forward should be.

Pros
  • Active ingredients are clinically proven effective for mild to moderate acne
  • Considered safe for long-term use
Cons
  • More expensive than similar product lines
  • May cause skin irritation during the first few weeks
  • Nonactive ingredients may cause adverse side effects

How to Use Proactiv+

With the Proactiv+ product line, Proactiv claims to have combined the principles of Combination Therapy with “Smart Target” technology to send acne-fighting medication to your pores for healthier skin and fewer blemishes.

This technology purportedly delivers active ingredients directly into your pores to reduce the potential for dryness and irritation.

Proactiv+ is a three-step system designed to be used twice per day in the morning and evening. For each session, you will complete the following steps:

  1. Apply a coin-sized dollop of the Skin Smoothing Exfoliator to dampened skin, massaging it with a circular motion for two minutes. Rinse with warm water and pat until dry.

  2. Apply at least two pumps of Pore Targeting Treatment to your clean, dry skin and gently smooth it over your face, allowing it to absorb fully. Don’t wash it off!

  3. Apply at least a coin-sized amount of the Complexion Perfecting Hydrator to your dry skin, gently smoothing it over your face until it fully absorbs. You can apply more over the day as needed.

Proactiv+ is designed for long-term use. You might experience a two to four-week adjustment period as your skin gets used to the products’ active ingredients, during which you may find that your skin is dry, red, or irritated.

Note that Proactiv+ doesn’t claim to cure acne and that the company states your blemishes may return when you stop using the product line.

Analysis of Ingredients

Proactiv+’s three products include dozens of ingredients each, but the company only lists two active ingredients between the two of them: Benzoyl peroxide (2.5%) and salicylic acid (0.5%).

Benzoyl peroxide is a standard treatment option for mild to moderate acne. It works to kill bacteria and remove dead skin cells from your pores so that your skin stops getting inflamed and overproducing oil.

Though it’s considered safe for most people, benzoyl peroxide can produce side effects like skin irritation, excessive dryness, and itchiness or flakiness. Those with sunburns or naturally sensitive skin are most likely to react negatively.

Regarding concentration, a study from 1986 found that a 2.5% concentration of benzoyl peroxide was as effective as a 5% or 10% concentration and was less likely to cause harmful side effects than those concentrations. Another study from 2013 verifies these findings.

Salicylic acid is another common acne treatment. Like benzoyl peroxide, it works to unplug blocked pores so that dirt and oil are dislodged and your pimples shrink. It tends to work best for whiteheads and blackheads, rather than the pus-filled pimples that benzoyl peroxide targets.

As salicylic acid is milder than benzoyl peroxide, concentrations vary in prescription products from between 0.5 and 5%. Both salicylic acid and benzoyl peroxide target different types of acne, so Proactiv+ combines them for a full spectrum treatment.

Are there any Proactiv+ ingredients to worry about? Below are some compounds that have potential risk factors, as reported by the Environmental Working Group (EWG) database.

  • Ceteareth-20: This synthetic compound acts as an emulsifier and a surfactant in personal care products. Though considered safe for topical use, it shouldn’t be used with on damaged skin because you risk absorbing it into your bloodstream and possibly triggering organ damage or general irritation.

  • Sodium polyacrylate: This chemical polymer is often added to products for its absorbency powers. It’s considered toxic if swallowed and can irritate the eyes on contact. Some people also experience skin irritation when using it topically.

  • Potassium hydroxide: Also known as lye, this inorganic material is highly caustic and is used both in soapmaking and as a thickening agent. Too much exposure can lead to skin and eye irritation, and it may be fatal if swallowed in pure form.

  • Sodium hydroxide: Like potassium hydroxide, this compound has strong corrosive qualities and can cause skin and eye irritation if you are overexposed to it.

  • Phenoxyethanol: This common cosmetic preservative is linked to skin irritation ranging from eczema and hives to life-threatening allergic reactions.

  • Kojic acid: Made from multiple types of fungi, kojic acid is often used topically and is considered safe at concentrations under 1%. Some people experience skin redness and irritation even at this concentration.

There’s also evidence that its longterm use can make you more susceptible to sunburns, which is part of the reason why Proactiv recommends that you always apply sunscreen when using its products.

Key Takeaways

Because of how potent these compounds are, especially when combined, many people experience dryness and irritation for the first few weeks of use. You might want to start with smaller amounts and gradually work up to the recommended doses if your skin reacts badly.

Pricing and Kits

On the company website, Proactiv+’s pricing ranges depending on which kit you purchase:

Price What’s Included
Proactiv+ Teen Kit $39.95 (free shipping)
  • Proactiv+ 3-Step System
  • Blackhead Dissolving Gel
  • Emergency Blemish relief
Proactiv+ Complete Kit $39.95 (free shipping)
  • Proactiv+ 3-Step System
  • Clarifying Night Cream
  • Advanced Dark Spot Correcting Serum
Proactiv+ 3-Step System $29.95 ($5.99 shipping)
  • Proactiv+ 3-Step System

You can also choose one bonus gift to be included in your order:

  • Gel Head Brush Set: cushioned skin polisher that exfoliates while removing makeup, dirt, oil, and other impurities.

  • Oil Control Kit: T-zone oil absorber that makes your pores smaller and provides up to eight hours of shine-free skin. It also includes an Amazonian clay mask.

  • Deluxe Brush Kit: Cleansing brush with three different brush heads to remove dirt, makeup, oil, bacteria, and other impurities.

You can then decide whether you will receive standard-sized 30-day-supply products or larger-sized 90-day supply bottles for three times the price.

Each purchase automatically signs you up for a subscription. Approximately every twelve weeks, you will receive a new 90-day supply of Proactiv+ products (the larger-sized products) for the same purchase price as your first order, plus $2.99-$3.99 for shipping. This 90-day payment is broken down into three monthly payments.

You can adjust how often you receive new Proactiv+ kits through your online account from every four weeks to every 20 weeks. This is also where you can pause or cancel your subscription at any time.

All Proactiv+ orders qualify for a 60-day money-back guarantee. Even empty bottles qualify for this return. To initiate a return, you can place the merchandise back in a box with an original invoice and send it to Proactiv, 6390 Commerce Court, Groveport, OH 43125.

Your money will be refunded, minus shipping costs. If you need further help, contact Proactiv+ customer care at (800) 309-4796.

Analysis of Customer Reviews

More than 30 HighYa readers have left reviews for Proactiv+, and they average 2.7 stars overall. Here are some of the most common comments.

Common Compliments:

  • Effective for long-term acne reduction
  • Clears up acne problems quickly
  • Led to smoother, clearer skin
  • Worked better for many than traditional Proactiv products

Common Complaints:

  • Bad customer service experiences (difficulties canceling subscription accounts)
  • Many customers didn’t realize they were signing up for a subscription
  • Too harsh for long term use
  • Some users developed cystic acne after using Proactiv+

Proactiv+ vs. Popular Alternatives

For those shopping around for a multi-step acne treatment kit, it pays to look at other options, including the original Proactiv line as well as two bestselling brands on Amazon.

Proactiv+ Proactiv Original Acne Free Clear Zit Acne Treatment
Price $29.99–$50 for 30-day (depending on whether you sign up for a subscription) $44.95 for a 60-day supply $18.38 for a 60-day supply $19.99 for a 60-day supply
Set Includes
  • Skin Smoothing Exfoliator

  • Pore Targeting Treatment

  • Complexion Perfecting Hydrator

  • Renewing Cleanser

  • Revitalizing Toner

  • Repairing Treatment

  • Oil-Free Acne Cleanser

  • Witch Hazel Mattifying Toner

  • Oil-Free Acne Lotion

  • Pore Targeted Exfoliator

  • Pore Targeted Treatment

  • Pore Targeted Hydrator

Active Ingredients Benzoyl peroxide (2.5%), salicylic acid (0.5%). Benzoyl peroxide (2.5%) Benzoyl peroxide (2.5%) Benzoyl peroxide (2.5%), Salicylic acid (0.5%)

What’s interesting about this comparison is that it shows that each of these product lines contains the same primary active ingredient—benzoyl peroxide at 2.5% concentration.

This makes sense, as we stated earlier that this compound is commonly used in acne medications and that a 2.5% concentration is considered the right ratio for skin benefits without causing excessive irritation.

Seeing this similar ingredients list, it becomes less clear why Proactiv+ costs more. In fact, you will pay almost five times more for a 60-day supply of Proactiv+ (without a subscription) than if you purchased the Clear Zit Acne Treatment Kit from Amazon, which contains the same ratio of benzoyl peroxide and salicylic acid.

Maybe the brand recognition and the extra ingredients in Proactiv make this higher pricing worth it, but there’s a good chance you might achieve similar results from a far cheaper product.

The Bottom Line

The Proactiv product line has been an acne-fighting leader for decades, and Proactiv+ builds on that legacy with powerful ingredients that are clinically proven to combat mild to moderate acne.

This kit works both to prevent and clear up existing acne, and it’s formulated to be mild enough for daily use. However, this means you might need to commit to using it long term if you want to maintain any results you achieve.

Proactiv+ is a premium brand, and it has pricing to match. You can find far cheaper alternatives available, many of which should work almost identically since they contain the same active ingredients.

Overall, we think that Proactiv+ is one viable option out of many for addressing your skin outbreaks. Just keep in mind that you might need to invest in prescription-strength products if you deal with cystic acne or other severe cases.


Customer Reviews

Start your review of Proactiv Plus:
  • 36 Customer Reviews
  • 47% Recommend This Company
2.7 out of 5
5 star: 25% 4 star: 16% 3 star: 8% 2 star: 0% 1 star: 50%

 Our Promise to You

To safeguard you and ensure helpfulness and relevance, our compliance team manually assess every customer review before it goes live.

We have a zero-tolerance policy for fake reviews, and companies cannot control or alter any reviews at any time.

Sort reviews by:

  • Proactiv Plus Review

    • By Amanda ,
    • Texas,
    • Jul 11, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    Started using Proactiv Plus in September 2014. I've been having breakouts. This stuff really helped my skin. I hardly have anymore breakouts. Love, love, love, this stuff.

    Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend


  • BEWARE of their false advertising

    • By Meg,
    • Los Angeles, CA,
    • Jan 12, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    BEWARE! Proactive Plus made my skin much worse and bleached my sheets. And the company has the WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE ever and I ended up having to dispute the charge with my credit card company. Do not give your business to this dishonest company.

    Proactive Plus advertises a 60-day money back guarantee. When I called for a refund, the agent gave me another phone number to call. I tried it several times and nobody ever picked up or returned my messages. I called the main line again, and the agent gave me the phone number for their “Escalation Department.” I left a message there too and nobody ever called me back. They advertise the 60-day money back guarantee in commercials and on their website, but make it impossible to get a refund. I wish someone would file a lawsuit for their FALSE ADVERTISING.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


  • Caused cystic acne for me too.

    • By Miranda Ottem,
    • Antioch, CA,
    • Jul 9, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    I found this review page in hopes of finding tips on how to make a successful return of the unopened 90 day supply. I knew about the automatic ordering, just forgot to cancel. I've been really stressed and busy so I figured my breakouts were from that. Then I realized after reading other people had cystic acne after starting Proactiv Plus, that's when I connected the dots. I'm so pissed, I can't wait to call to cancel.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


  • Amazing Proactiv Plus

    • By Donna,
    • Scotland,
    • Jul 7, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    Like everyone else I've tried all the spot lotion and potions to no avail, but after getting Proactiv Plus I am totally impressed with this stuff. My spots are gone and my skin is looking so good it's brilliant. I love to be able to just walk on by the spot treatments isle now and it feels great getting up in the morning to a gorgeous complexion. A massive thank you to Rodan & Fields, well done.

    Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend


  • Angry and disappointed

    • By Nina,
    • Jul 19, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    I have never had acne issues, my main problem was discoloration and I saw the ad for this product. So my mom signed up for it and I got the product which is suppose to be a miracle treatment. On the contrary, after few days after using it, I noticed a cluster of acne on my face and other reactions. However, I still decided to continue using it with the hope that it will stop and do as it's meant to. I was disappointed that I still didn't see any good results. Instead, my face was getting worse with acne and breakouts so I had to go back to my former face treatment.

    Long story short, this product has ruined my face by leaving painful acne marks which I have never had and it's getting worse because it's not clearing even after returning to my old cream. I wish I would have not started this cream. I would choose my old smooth face with discoloration than this sore face.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


  • It really works

    • By Channtria,
    • Modesto, CA,
    • Aug 13, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    I never tried Proactiv because when my sister tried it, it was too strong for them and they broke out a lot. I been having this ugly post acne mark for almost three months and tried almost every product you can name. Neutrogena, clean and clear, Clearasil​, Jojoba oil, tea tree oil, Olay. It doesn't want to work. So I order the Proactiv Plus to give it a try. been using it for only just three days and my post acne is starting to fade and my texture is coming back in. You will break out a little when you first use it, but do not give up on it too fast, it really works.

    Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend


  • The Original Proactiv is better

    • By Chrystal Hubbard,
    • Omaha, NE,
    • Jun 8, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    The original Proactiv worked miracles for me, yes it's expensive but it's worth it. Nothing works better than it for me. I always am told I have the best, most clear skin and I thank the original Proactiv for that. I was so excited to hear they were making a Proactiv plus and I thought it was going to be better. I was wrong. Not only did I pay $30.00 more dollars just for the small package of Proactiv plus, it didn't work for me. I broke out as if I wasn't using any skin care at all. I was extremely disappointed. If you're like me, use the original Proactiv. The original Proactive never ever did that to me, it always worked wonders and I was never disappointed with it and I have been using it for 10 years now. Minus the sad 4 weeks I used Proactiv plus.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


  • Never again.

    • By H.D.,
    • Arkansas,
    • Jun 29, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    I'm 42 and suffer with mild acne so I ordered Proactiv Plus and after two weeks, my face broke out in huge open sores all over my face and neck. I knew there'd be a break out period but what I'm going through is not just a normal breakout. These are huge, open, raw sores. I was a military combat medic so I knew it wasn't anything other than the Proactiv and these sores still remain on my face three weeks after my last use of Proactiv and don't seem to be getting better very quickly.

    I will never use this again nor will I recommend this crap to anyone and to make things worse, they continue to charge me long after I canceled and keep telling me it will take six weeks to get my money back. Bad customer service, worse product. Buyer beware.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


  • Thank God.

    • By Kira,
    • Mount Vernon, NY,
    • Jul 20, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    I had to write a review, and I never write reviews! Thank God for the doctors who made Proactiv Plus. This stuff worked immediately on my face, in a week I noticed a difference. Better yet, my acne, (I'm talking about cystic acne, black heads, acne scars, and acne marks) went away in a week. The Proactiv Plus system works together in harmony as my texture changed and my pores got smaller. I've tried everything. I've suffered from acne since I was 19 and now I'm 40. God bless the doctors who invented this product. I'm thankful and appreciative.

    Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend


  • Original is WAY Better

    • By Victoria,
    • Newfoundland, Canada,
    • Jun 19, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    I had been using original Proactiv for many years and was a very happy customer (the only system that has ever helped with my terrible acne and extremely oily skin), when I saw the ads for Proactiv Plus, I decided to give it a shot. I gave it a chance for three weeks before finally admitting defeat and calling it quits. I can't remember the last time my skin was this badly broken out – large pimples covering my entire face and oil that no amount of make up or blotting sheets could tame, not to mention pores you can see from space.

    I am so deeply disappointed by this product and the money I wasted. The product has a lovely fragrance and is packaged nicely, end of positive traits. It didn't even make my skin feel clean.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


  • Buyer beware.

    • By Cindy,
    • Houston, TX,
    • Jun 26, 2015
    Overall Experience:

    I started with the 30 day supply (smaller bottles). After 30 days I didn't see a significant change in my acne. So, of course, I started using the bigger sized products when the smaller bottles were done and I waited 60 days to see if my skin would improve. It did not. So I decided to return the products for my money back guarantee. Well I only got refunded for the larger bottles which is what I sent back. The smaller bottles I had used and thrown away after they were finished were not refunded. Make sure you save them even if you are done with them so that you can get your money back if the system doesn't work. I called and even spoke to a supervisor. They are worthless and did nothing. I am glad they didn't work, because I hate to do business with companies that don't care about being 100% behind their product. I now use Alpha Hydrox and it's working wonders. And so much cheaper. Google it.

    Bottom Line: No, I would not recommend this to a friend


Showing 1-11 of 36

Write a Review for Proactiv Plus!

Share your experience to help others discover great products!

Write a Review
Proactiv+ Review: All You Need to Know