The Farmer’s Dog Review: Is It Worth It?

By Lydia Noyes
HighYa Staff
Published on: Aug 26, 2019

What Is The Farmer’s Dog?

The Farmer’s Dog is a subscription pet food company that promises to deliver fresh and healthy dog food to your home on a predetermined schedule.

The company claims that their meals are crafted with simple, human-grade ingredients chosen to ensure that your pet receives optimal nutrition without you having to deal with inconvenient trips to the store, pricy retail markups, or unnecessary preservatives.

Subscription dog food is a hot trend, but does this fresh food brand make enough sense to consider switching over from kibble? Here, we’ll help you decide.

What Distinguishes The Farmer’s Dog from Other Pet Food?

The Farmer’s Dog makes it clear that their target customer is the pet-owner who doesn’t think his or her pets deserve lower quality food than their families. All their dog food is made with fresh ingredients and delivered on your schedule for optimal convenience.

Each Farmer’s Dog recipe was designed by vets and can be optimized based on your pet’s breed, age, activity level, dietary sensitivities, and more.

The company considers its food a smarter choice than kibble for picky eaters as well as for dogs who are overweight or have other health problems.

According to the company website, all Farmer’s Dog food is prepared in USDA-approved kitchens where it is lightly cooked at low temperatures and flash frozen before shipping.

It claims that the brand’s subscription business model makes it possible to distribute pet food that is fresher than what is typically available at the grocery store, as it doesn’t languish in a warehouse for months before being sold.

This purportedly gives consumers more control over what they feed their canine.

What Ingredients Are in The Farmer’s Dog?

All Farmer’s Dog ingredients are human-grade (never feed-grade) and comply with USDA standards. Each meal is based around one or more protein sources that are mixed with produce and supplemented with beneficial vitamins and minerals.

The company website states that each recipe is balanced to comply with the Association of Animal Feed Control Officials standards.

Below are the full ingredients within each of The Farmer’s Dog meal options at the time of writing:

  • Turkey: Turkey, parsnips, chickpeas, carrot, broccoli, spinach, fish oil, vitamins, and minerals

  • Beef: Beef, sweet potato, lentils, carrots, USDA beef liver, water, kale, sunflower seeds, fish oil, vitamins, and minerals

  • Pork: USDA pork, sweet potato, green beans, cauliflower, USDA pork liver, fish oil, vitamins, and minerals

Full nutritional facts for every meal is available on the website after completing the meal plan questionnaire.

How Does a Farmer’s Dog Subscription Work?

What you’ll pay for The Farmer’s Dog food depends on the eating requirements for your dog.

The company website states that plans start at $2 per day, and you can find your exact costs by completing the online questionnaire.

This online questionnaire addresses specifics about your pet, including its age, gender, breed, weight, activity level, and current dietary requirements. Your answers will determine what size portions are recommended and how much they will cost every week.

I filled out a test account to see what the food prices would be for my 18-pound Pomeranian mix and 45-pound Australian cattle dog, both of whom are under five years old, at a good weight and moderately active.

The Farmer’s Dog suggested I feed my Pomeranian meals made from turkey, beef, and pork, and totaled my weekly cost at $24.92. My cattle dog was offered the same proteins, and his food plan cost $43.57 per week.

Further research showed that the weekly cost to feed seven-pound dogs was $13.22, and ninety-pound dogs was about $92.46.

The Farmer’s Dog currently ships for free across the contiguous United States. Signing up for an order enrolls you in a subscription plan for recurring deliveries that range from every two to twelve weeks.

All food will arrive chilled and in serving packs that can be placed in the refrigerator for immediate use or in the freezer for longer storage.

Once you have an online account, you can change your delivery address, rush or delay shipments, or adjust the amount of food included in each shipment. The brand ships across the continental United States and states that their meals are delivered in eco-friendly packaging.

You can always pause or cancel your subscription without penalty. For help with more specific questions, you can contact customer service at help@thefarmersdog.com.

Farmers Dog vs. Competition

The Farmer’s Dog is far from the only dog food delivery service available today. The following chart highlight some of the key differences between other popular brands.

The Farmer’s Dog Spot and Tango Pet Plate Ollie
Cost 7-Pound dog: $13.22/week.
90-pound dog: $92.46/week
7-pound dog: $21.56/week.
90-pound dog: $110.28/week
Cost depends on the size of the dog and delivery frequency: three weeks is the default. 7-pound dog: $17.29 to $19.89/week.
90-pound dog: $69.90 to $80.38/week
Cost Per Serving (2 per day) 7-pound dog: $0.94.
90-pound dog: $6.60.
7-pound dog: $0.71 to $0.84.
90-pound dog: $3.57 to $4.41.
Small dog: $1.25 to $2.35.
Medium dog: $3 to $4.
Large dog: $4.50 to $6.50
XL dog: $8 to $9.5
$1.32 to $5.36 per meal
Delivery Range Ships free across 48 states. Sold online and in pet specialty stores across Manhattan. Free shipping across 48 lower States. Lower 48 states. Lower 48 states.
Customization Level Can choose between meals made from turkey, beef, and pork. Can choose between three pre-made meals containing turkey and red quinoa, beef and millet, and lamb and brown rice. Possible to purchase “topper plan” to mix meals with regular dog food for a lower price. Choose from meals with chicken, beef, turkey, and lamb. Choose from beef, chicken, turkey, and lamb. For large breed dogs, it’s possible to purchase full meals or choose “toppers” of 25% of their nutritional needs.
Shipping Information Meals are shipped and billed every two to twelve weeks after a two-week taste trial, can be paused or canceled at any time. All purchases require signing up for an auto-renewing subscription. It’s possible to pause or cancel at any time. Free shipping, deliveries sent out Monday to ensure a Wednesday or Thursday delivery. Two-week auto-delivery that can be canceled at any time.

As this chart should make clear, the cost for feeding your pet will vary considerably depending on his or her size and the brand you choose.

Spot and Tango appear to be the most affordable option we looked at, and it wins points from us by offering a “topper plan” that lets you buy smaller amounts of fresh food to incorporate their food into your pet’s standard meals and keep costs down.

While you can conceivably do this with other plans like The Farmer’s Dog as well, you’ll receive enough food per shipment for full meals which might lead to waste if your pet doesn’t eat it fast enough.

Regarding shipping and customization, these plans all seem similar to us. Each one ship throughout the lower 48 states and they all offer a variety of meals made from human-grade ingredients with different protein sources, though they don’t provide much menu customization beyond that.

If you’re unsure which to purchase, we suggest trialing a few different brands to see which your pet best responds to.

What Do Customers Think of The Farmer’s Dog?

Online reviews abound for The Farmer’s Dog, so we looked at several to see whether people like this pet food brand.

Popular dog website The Canine Journal scores this supplier at 4.35/5 and gives it high points for nutritional value and customization.

Some of the site’s positives include that the meals are never deep-frozen before delivery, the food is free of preservatives, and that the auto-ship program offers plenty of flexibility.

The primary drawback noted is that the food arrives so fresh that it doesn’t last long without spoiling. If your pet doesn't eat it within three or four days, you’ll need to store it in the freezer.

Business Insider also offers insight into this brand. While reviewer Kate Barrington noted that the meals are more expensive than traditional pet food, she appreciated that the meals arrived pre-portioned and that the company was transparent about their ingredients.

The primary downside she noted was that the bags weren’t resealable, and they often became messy when the same was used for multiple meals.

Opinions from other review sites seem to match these perspectives. A few other comments we noticed from customers included that they wished the company offered meals for dogs with allergies or on prescription diets.

Others noted that it took their pets a few days to adjust to the food and that they had mild digestive problems in the meantime. Overall though, The Farmer’s Dog reviews seem overwhelmingly positive.

The Bottom Line

As this review hopefully made clear, we think that The Farmer’s Dog is a smart way to supply your pet with fresher dog food.

The company lets you select food based on your pet’s specifications, and its subscription program offers plenty of flexibility in delivery frequency. This makes it more convenient than rushing to the store every time you’re low on dog food.

You’ll pay a lot more for this kind of food than traditional kibble, but The Farmer’s Dog pricing is aligned with the costs of competitors.

You’ll naturally pay a lot more if you have a larger dog, and it’s worth considering that you’ll also need more fridge and freezer space to store the food deliveries than those who have smaller pooches.

If the costs are something you are comfortable with, we think it makes sense to try out The Farmer’s Dog.

We read overwhelmingly glowing reviews from people who switched their pets over, so there’s a good chance that you and your pet will be satisfied if you do the same thing.

» See Also: Dog Supplements 101: A Detailed Beginner’s Guide

Write a Review for The Farmer’s Dog!

Share your experience to help others shop smarter & discover great products.

Write a Review